Le Petite Moustique
by Simonkasprzak

Comment:
Very nice picture, although I feel the main subject is too small (or maybe I just need some glasses...). Anyway, I like the overall feel of the image. What I truly dislike is the large border and believe the picture would be greatly enhanced if you eliminated it.

Civil War Cannon - Will the smoke ever clear?
by glad2badad

Comment:
Nice subject and composition. Too bad the sky is blown out and the cannon lacks a little contrast to the bg. Anyway, nice approach of the challenge.

Pink Flower
by I Enjoy Ham

Comment:
Though you have a nice, average macro shot of a flower, it doesnt fit the challenge.I feel It's not minimalistic and the main subject fills almost the whole picture area. Nice colors and composition (perhaps cropping the bottom area would work out nicer), though.

Button
by ckdake

Comment:
While it is indeed a minimalistic image, I feel it's not an interesting one. Besides, the main subject here -the belly button- is very soft, almost out of focus. The composition is, however, fine. Better luck next time.

Photo---9editedcattonge.jpg
by gwendy

Comment:
Very nice shot. The cat's head in on perfect focus and Dof is good - the background is perfectly blurred out and has a nice saturated green. Perhaps the photo has too much contrast. Anyway, pretty good.

Photo--12cat.jpg
by gwendy

Comment:
In this one, the focus in on the cat's back, when it should be on its eyes or nose or sharp teeth lol. That's the only thing I have to point out.

Out, Out, Damn Spot
by Di

Comment:
Great, great shot of zebra stripes... However, one can barelly see the "damned spot", which is intended to be the main point of the image... That, of course, is a turn off. I feel that, in a different context, I would have scored this image much higher...
Anyway, very nice shot and good job.

Orange # 5
by LowLght

Comment:
Well, I dont think you have the most interesting subject... However, I must say your image is rather catchy and appealing, with its simple and minimalistic forms. The colors are very well chosen and produce a pretty good combination. Tecnichally, no flaws to point out. Nice job.

door knob
by robadsy

Comment:
Nice minimalistic shot - basic forms and colors, strong composition and perspective. I only feel that the imperfections on the blue part are too visible, which is a bit of a turn off... Maybe by smoothing or blurring it a bit, the image could improve... I'm not sure - I'm no expert on photo editing... But it sure does stand out. Good job.

Thicker than Water
by conglett

Comment:
The concept is very clever - creating a pattern, in which the strong point of the image emerges -, but I'm not sure about its execution... I don´t think the drop of blood (??) is such a strong point, perhaps due to its framing and dimension... I feel you ended up with an image less interesting than it was supoosed to (and the reflection of the light is a bit distracting too). Anyway, 6 for originality and effort.