Stripes
by melismatica

Comment:
I like many aspects of this image.

I really like the way that the lime green stripe and the red mesh with black background make the blue stripes pop out more. I also like the composition - the choice of how close to get to the subject in order to position the green stripe and red mesh just so in the image; taking up just that amount of space out of the overall blue.

My main dislike is lack of detail in the texture. The soft focus was probably deliberate but doesn't work for me. I'm finding myself straining to see texture that isn't there and that's making my viewing experience slightly frustrated.

Overall my feelings about this image are much more positive than negative.

Which one is named "Laurie?"
by photom

Comment:
I gave this image a vote of 5 because although we have lots of feet they didn't seem to stand out to me within the image much. Also because the image is quite dark and the focus isn't wonderful and the cropping doesn't do anything for me - one bird has lost his head. I do like the expression on the second (and most focused) bird.

"Poverty is a veil that obscures the face of greatness"
by Loki

Comment:
A beautiful image. One would never expect to see an image of feet being used so successfully to convey poverty. The black and white treatment focuses our attention on the textures of the worn and dirty socks and shoes. The jeans don't appear to be correspondingly dirty and worn though, which is a little strange. 8

Darling Sister Toes
by debitipton

Comment:
I don't usually like selective desaturation because so many of the examples seem to use it for the sake of using it rather than because it's use really adds something to the shot that wouldn't be achieved with all colour or all black and white. In your shot I really like it's use because, to me, the colour really highlights the message that skin colour isn't important and that people of different races often have more in common than they have not in common. Nicely composed too, simple and unusual. Texture and pattern of floor surface complements rather than distracts. 8

On the Road Again
by tyt2000

Comment:
Such a beautiful and simple image. I particularly like how understated but perfect the light is - low enough to only just bring out the details in the foreground cobbles but enough to make the pedestrian into a solid silhouette. Nicely composed too. 9

Miles and Miles
by adrenalindream

Comment:
A lovely idea and the shallow DOF definitely adds something. I am not keen on the ratio being quite so wide and short. I think it would feel more balanced if nearer to a more standard ratio. I understand that would require the text to be positioned a little differently or perhaps just a slightly different composition. Just my two pennies anyway. 9

Huckleberry Had it Right!
by elsapo

Comment:
What an evocative image! The reflections in the water really convey a hot sunny day which just calls out for a cooling dip of the feet. Not sure about the decision to go black and white - hard to tell without seeing the same image in colour. Composition works well, you have included just enough of the legs and I like the way they come into the frame from the respective lower corners. 9

splash!
by Alexys

Comment:
The detail and pattern in the water and reflections is just exquisite. 10

Pinned
by movieman

Comment:
Beautiful, sensuous, well composed, works excellently in toned black and white. 10

Feet & Up
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Not sure why I like this so much - I think it's because of the unusual composition and the way that an important element of the "story" - the screen hiding the people whose feet we are seeing - is actually providing a block of solid black to balance the shadow in the lower right corner. Composition is just so excellent. 10