Blank Generation
by surfinbird

Comment:
The toning adds a new dimension that is nice but the model's structure is a bit disturbing to me. He looks very underweight. I was going to give this a 4/5 but writing this comment has allowed me to view it for a few seconds. Just because he is not physically perfect shouldn't make it a bad photo. In fact, the pose is very interesting coupled with the cutoff head. If the purpose of your photo was to make the viewer a bit uneasy then you succeeded. It was the same tact I took on mine. I'm going to consider this decent/good art and score it higher.

Unforgiven II
by kiumars_kashani

Comment:
Mucho oversharpened. I love sharp pictures but it is unflattering to this beautiful model.

Allison
by OdysseyF22

Comment:
I like everything about it except the hand/arm. Because it's the same color range and OOF, it kind of adds to her face instead of framing it.

Grandmother
by choppers

Comment:
Great lighting, horrible pose. Having her look the complete other way combined with the baby looking away gives a complete feeling of disconnect.

Dark Thinker
by J-Me

Comment:
Lighting is too harsh for this pose. I like the pose, the model etc but the strong light kills it.

Georgi
by pawdrix

Comment:
Seems too flat (contrast). I would like to see her face brighter.

Eye of the Beholder
by vertigoreality

Comment:
Way too harsh of lighting. I don't like the blown out face nor the heavy shadow it cast.

spontaneous
by lenyn

Comment:
The lighting might be a little too harsh for this photo. It's a small child and I would prefer softer lighting.

Rebecca
by CalliopeKel

Comment:
I like the angle, the DOF, expression.

Eastern Mystery
by AlexSaberi

Comment:
Nicely done all the way around