Devon
by dwterry

Comment:
If you like this shot, that is all that matters but personally I think you went a little overboard with the contrast. Still a good shot, but IMO only slightly above average (and that is not bad, there are a lot of good shots in the challenge) 6

Last Rays of the Day on the Frozen Dome
by Gauti

Comment:
I have a smilar shot of the Pearl in colour but it is not as good as this one, excellent capture. 8

Soothing Crashes
by soccerdad

Comment:
Soothing crashes indeed. Looks like a very good scene to go to and you captured it well, somehow I get the feeling that it would look good in colour but don´t get me wrong, I like the shot as it is.

Sanctuary
by Konador

Comment:
Very good shot, I have taken lots of photographs in churches and I know how hard it is to light them propery and I think you did a superb job. 8

Bistra
by Natator

Comment:
Awesome shot, a very good portrait and I love the lighting. I love the composition too but I think if you cropped a bit tighter it would look good too. Anyway an easy 10 from me, hope you do well.

Two Women
by Gatorguy

Comment:
I don´t get the framing here, what is with the HUGE white border on the right and the small one on the bottom. Anyway I don´t get it (if there is anything to get at all) and it just plain ruins it for me for this looks like a promising photo. You got good lighting, interesting subjects and although it looks a bit soft that is not neccesarily a bad thing, I probably would have given this photo 6-7 but I am one of those narrow minded fools that can´t look past the border on the right.

Beer dressed in black and white
by Pascal

Comment:
Too dark to really make out any details and while that is sometimes a good thing, in this case IMO it is not. Maybe this was intentional and then I just don´t get it perhaps but if not you should check out your monitor.

Bear Necessities
by awpollard

Comment:
Backround is really distracting, either recompose or use much shorter DOF but other than that not a bad shot, not exceptional either though.

Two Towers
by JohannesFrank

Comment:
Þessi er bara geðveik! Besta mynd sem ég hef nokkurntíman séð af Háteigskirkju og ég hef séð þær margar. 10 í einkunn. Ég veit að það má svo ekki í Basic editing en ef ég væri þú myndi ég "klóna" burt ljósastaurinn niðri í hægra horninu, hann stingur dálítið í augun.

For those of you who don´t speak Icelandic I am just simply drooling over this image...

Horus' Throne
by gloda

Comment:
Cool shadow effect, I like this shot.