GOT AIR?
by lentil

Comment:
I love the idea but the final outcome isn´t really hitting a spot with me as it is, I want too see more of the shoes, not just the soles. Anyway, one of the more original shots and I really like the DOF so I still gave it a higher than average score, 6 from me.

"These boots are made for walking"
by Structor

Comment:
Nice sky but I would have liked this shot a lot more if you had used a reflector or something to light up the boots more as IMHO they really blend in with the backround as it is. 6 from me.

Sympathy for Sheep
by CorySmith

Comment:
Nicely lit and I like the colours you used in this one, 7 from me.

Suzie Wong's Red Boots.
by modprod

Comment:
I don´t really want to offend you but the first thing that came to my mind was that I don´t really care for the pose, was this really the best you could come up with? Her standing up, or stretching her legs towards the camera and you using a wide angle lens to emphasize the boots or just anything other than just sitting there... Anyway, I like the lighting (even though that glare on her left knee is pretty "off" but I am sure you would have cloned that out if this hadn´t been a basic editing rules challenge) and composition and backround, definately above average in the challenge. 6 from me.

Shoe In Blue
by birdyblue

Comment:
Nice, I like the blue cast, dislike the tight framing. 6 from me.

Odor-Eaters???
by Nald

Comment:
Nice, love the green lightpainting, the boots don´t seem to be completely in focus though or this shot needs some sharpening, it´s hard to tell though as they are a little bit too dark for my taste. Anyway, nice shot, one of the more original in the challenge, I gave it an 7.

ol' boot on that thar post
by bruski

Comment:
Nice colours and great backround even though some of the clouds have blown out hightlights. Only to nitpick though I don´t really care for the glare that is on the boot, especially the one that is banana shaped dark brown sole part of the shoe. Still very nice, one of the better shots in the challenge, I gave it an 8.

Timberland: Go Anywhere
by cools98

Comment:
Nice idea but not really an outcome I am liking too much. I am assuming you were trying to capture the splash of the boot. In that case I would like to see more DOF with all of the droplets in focus cause IMHO this just looks messy. Nice try though but only a 5 from me as it is.

Freshly Shined Ones
by bucket

Comment:
Nice idea, I would have liked it better though if it had been framed slightly wider since you cut off the low part of the sign and the jar with the toothbrushes. Nice tones but maybe it´s just the screen I am looking at but it could be a little bit sharper. One of the better shots in the challenge, gave it a 7.

Don't you step on me with your...
by awpollard

Comment:
I am not really a big fan of the harsh lighting but you just barely pull it off but other than that I like this shot, those little blue/green men are funny and nice composition. 7 from me.