My Part
by maxbuten

Comment:
1. Good focus and detail
2. Good Colors
3. Interesting approach a play on challenge. [Part of the face and part in the hair]
4. Good lighting
5. Great photograph

What a pain to clean!
by jmlelii

Comment:
1. Great subject
2. Chrome it really stands out
3. Needs a large DOF, the top of tire is out of focus
4. Your angle of approach is good
5. Good photograph

Crystal Goblet
by typologic

Comment:
1. Good Close up
2. Great focus
3. Background color goes well with the subject
4. Good abstract photograph
5. Subject not that appealing to me but still a good photograph

Attacked!
by lcarterdavis

Comment:
1. Great micro
2. Great focus
3. Love the colors
4. Background on left [light part] a little distracting
5. Great photograph

Retired
by Brad

Comment:
If your subject is the broken tire [as title may suggest], I feel like it does not meet the challenge. But if your subject is the wagon, then it does. This is the dilemma of the voters. With that said I am giving most everyone the benefit of interpretation and you photo is great. Nice approach to the subject, I like the old style look, focus is amazing. Great work � 10.

Message edited by author 2004-10-13 00:44:58.

Sunset at Castle Hill
by BobsterLobster

Comment:
Congratulations on a great photograph!

Red Wheels.JPG
by artvet

Comment:
1. I agree, love the colors.
2. I like your approach at the subject.
3. But something is distracting me. I know the blown out sky is one thing, but something else. Is it possibly over saturated? Or over sharpened? I just cant put my finger on it. I am an amateur so I just cant figure it out. what about the picture as a whole is making my eyes jump around? As Ecce Signum said "it screams b&w" but that would be a shame to lose the rich colors.

BUT MOST OF ALL IT IS A GOOD PHOTOGRAPH WITH GREAT COLORS.
NOTE: This is an amateur opinion

Runaway Breakfast
by vasilkovaya

Comment:
Congrat's on your first ribbon. Good Work!

Cat Nap Interupted!
by myfelix

Comment:
I am sorry but I could not help but laugh when I say your photo. It looks like she is thinking, �come on give me a break here, can�t I get a good nap�. Your title is fitting. With that said a your photo technique sound as well. Hope you do well in the challenge

Wild Tule Elk
by sfalice

Comment:
I think you have done a great job of capturing an elk in true motion and what appears a natural setting. I don�t know if you got this shot at a zoo or in the wild but either way it is great. Great job, hope you do well in this challenge