Sneaking a Peak
by Nikolai1024

Comment:
Great approach to the challenge. Picture seems degraded at bottom right and I think a tighter crop, maybe down to just the door frame at the top and left side, not showing the wall would of been better. 5

Heaven's Hero
by msdoubletrouble

Comment:
Very nice shot but you subject is overpowered by the clouds IMO. This is a hard challenge to vote on and I think there is a lot of gray area so I will not say you did not meet the challenge. Good photograph 6

Reaching For The Sky
by atsxus

Comment:
If the subject would of been more interesting and in focus a little better it would of been a good shot. Wish you well in the challenge.

Tulip Junkyard
by stuffNjunk

Comment:
In a normal photograph I don't this would of worked. But in this challenge I does for me. You subject pops out and I like the DOF. 7

Boundaries
by dahkota

Comment:
Good photograph, I don't think your subject pop's out at me but you did a good job.

Alone up there.
by visual28

Comment:
Very nice work. Subject easily identifiable and has power in you photograph. I like the slight saturation increase and good lighting. 8

When Less is More
by DianaB

Comment:
Nice shot with good balance. Focus seems a bit soft but not bad, could be from jpg compression. Good job.

baseline
by zenelf

Comment:
This could of been a great photo but I find you subject a little dark. I would of liked to see it stand out more. Some may not even know what what the subject is because of the lack of detail. Still a good shot.

Only one lamppost
by THMB

Comment:
I find that your subject to centered within the picture and is not very strong. The nice sunset seems to overpower it. If it was not for the title I would find it hard to see the lamp as the subject. The lake seem to be a stronger subject in your picture. However you did capture a nice photograph and good lighting. Maybe a slight crop to tilt the horizon to left so it would be straight would of improved. I wish you well in the challenge.

The Yellow House
by Art Roflmao

Comment:
To Me, Absolutely stunning, I love it. Your photograph has great range, the lighting is spot on and not one blown highlight. But it goes beyond that. You are showing us were they sit to see a wonderful view instead of showing us the view itself. Very inviting to see a photograph such meaning. And the colors, I cannot say how much I love the contrast between the chairs themselves and the house. If I would of got to this photograph during voting I would of given it a 8. If I could have had the access to what the chairs were there for and the view one could see from them it would of scored a 10. I wish it would of scored higher because there is more in this picture than meets the eye. IMO you picked the right photograph. Congratulations and get a print of this one.
Scott W.