Psycho - Shower Scene - 1960
by jerowe

Comment:
The blood spray on the wall behind her doesnt flow with the image, it seems out of place. I think a shot without it would have been stronger. Her facial expression is good, but she looks pretty, and if I were screaming for my life I dont think I would look that pretty lol. I think the editing is really nice, sharp, clean, focused. Also, this shot has been done to death, to do something like this you have to be almost perfect, this is close... just a few things keep me from scoring it higher than 7. so.. 7! Good Luck :)

Shower Scene from Psycho
by scarbrd

Comment:
She doesn't really look like she is screaming.. more like a sneeze. I think more elements could have been added to make this a better image, props, better facial expression, etc.. The editing is great, it has that psycho vibe, but not quite there... :)

Almost Famous
by nicoledee

Comment:
I think you have captured the essence of the challenge. Every detail in this image says "Almost Famous". The t-shirt, the reflection, the type of glasses, the coloring, the grain... its just really really nice! Good Job 9

L’ Equipier (2004 French film about a Breton Lighthouse Keeper)
by charliebaker

Comment:
aside from the topic of the challenge, this shot is absolutely beautiful. It screams I AM MAN, or STRENGTH. I have not seen this movie, but it makes me want to see it. Stunning. 9

New York City
by AP

Comment:
nice take on the challenge. i love the duotone, reminds me of Dark City or some movie.. In a challenge filled with "new wannabe" photos, this tops them all. My only 10.

Enter your comment here, and then cast your vote . . .
by charliebaker

Comment:
I just do not consider this a real photograph. It may very well be an actual photograph, but its a photo of text. Its bland, its not aesthetically pleasing, it lacks creativity, its just not for me.

My New Handset
by bnilesh

Comment:
a nice stock shot. love the golden tones and the reflection. a nice shot!

Stanley's First Autumn
by GolferDDS

Comment:
the props and lighting are really good. If Stanley were posed a bit better.. lying down, looking at the camera, etc, the shot would be much better. Its a really nice set up.

New Pastels
by robst

Comment:
one of my favorites from this challenge. i love the colors, the way you didn't have a rainbow of colors but a variety of the same hues. also love the round pastel in the middle, the focus is good, and the shot meets the challenge. My only critique would be the background. I would either like to see this on a crisp white backdrop, commercial shot/stock, or something unique.. the gray is drab and takes away some of the beauty of the earth tones. overall a pleasing shot, have fun with your new pastels!

Brand new puppy!!
by Cboydrun

Comment:
love the fisheye. the dof is nice, it is technically well shot and the subject (due to the lens used) is comical and overall it makes for a great shot.