Swamp Flyer
by coolhar

Comment:
Nice capture. I'm really impressed how you have managed to capture the bird that clearly. I has great colors and definition and nice choice in DoF. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <8>

Playful Messengers
by Sonda

Comment:
I'm not fond of the high contrast of the birds wings or the soft focus. I find it to be a very distracting. I also find that the photo has a over edited look to it. Good luck in this challenge.

Standing Watch
by Jewellian

Comment:
Your score may be a little off because for some reason when I was glancing at the thumbs somehow your photo got rated as a 2 when I hadn't even started voting yet. Anyways with that being said and hopefully corrected, I find the size of your photo to be huge even on this 21" monitor and the grass seems a little OoF. The sun is also throwing a high contrast onto the from of the bird and the white part of the head that also gives the appearence of being a little OoF. However I like the shot and find that the semi hidden bird in the sand is very well done and adds that little extra that a lot of photos don't have. I really like the definition in the goose and all in al is well composed. Well done and good luck in this challenge.

untitled
by chele

Comment:
I'm not fond of the brightness of the photo and find it adds more distraction and grare then needed. I don't really see a primary subject or frame for that matter. Good luck in this challenge. <4>

let go
by VinceDoss

Comment:
I find the colors appear to have a washed look which could be caused by to much contrast or incorrect white balance or perhaps the subject itself. I find the subject to be over framed causing a great loss on the subject of the photo. Good luck in this challenge. <4>

Naturally Framed Entry
by MrAnalogy

Comment:
Nice photo altho I'm not sure how it meets the challenge. Excelent color and clarity but I'm not fussy on the levelness of the photo. The photo has a leaning right feeling to it. Perhaps a 1-2 degree rotation CCW would correct that. I really like the clear blue sky against the bright green trees and cannot wonder if that is your frame (nature). Either way a beautiful photo. Good luck in this challenge. <7>

Centered in Foliage
by K-Rob

Comment:
In my opinion the subject is not naturally framed but has a natural backdrop or background. The photo itself has great colors, clarity, has lots of detail and has a nice DoF. Good luck in this challenge. <5>

Hull
by Mr_Pants

Comment:
I'm not fond of this photo for his challenge because I think there is more frame then subject. Not only that but I had to re-read your title to fully understand what the photo was about. I think this photo would have done better in the rusted challenge. Good luck in this challenge. <4>

The Doorway
by Coley

Comment:
I've looked at this photo several times now and have yet to see the frame. It's a nice portrait with excellent clarity, contrast and the lack of color really makes this photo unique but in my opinion it does not meet the challenge. <5>

Rust
by eyesightphoto

Comment:
I wish the pressure gauge was clean to make it stand out more in the photo. I like the framing and clarity of this photo and find the photo to have an overall pleasing feel to it. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <7>