Unexpected Floral Puzzle
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
I can see how this represents serendipity, because the flowers are not where they should be. I like the way you've composed this as well, and the exposure is spot on. The geometry of the sidewalk works well too. One of my two favorites to ribbon.

Equestrian
by HRoxas

Comment:
Interesting perspective, very nice sky.

Wonder Valley: Yosemite
by Imagineer

Comment:
Super scene--super clarity! Well done.

Leviathan
by Imagineer

Comment:
Beautiful! I see a ribbon in the near future for this.

Tug-O-War
by rcrawford

Comment:
Funny and perfect for the challenge. Well shot too (though after the challenge is over it would be a good idea to clone out that distracting yellow tube in the background.)

2 HP
by TrollMan

Comment:
Wondderful shot. One of my top pics for this challenge

Lightness
by ccjp

Comment:
Very nice; I too would recommend cropping this to get a solid black natural border. You might also want to clone out the small vertical lighter area on the right. The next question is whether or not to keep it centered: you might experiment with adding a small amount of canvas at the bottom to force the image to the top third and make this a vertical orientation; but that's hard for me to see here, it might also work centered or as shot off vertical center.

Nice shot.

wheel graveyard
by fstopopen

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club:

Impressions: I like the concept, and the shot of the tires with great DOF works well. I particularly like that we get a closeup of a tire in the foreground which looks like it has pretty uneven tire wear.

Improvements: Looks like your camera failed you a bit, as there appears to be purple fringing around the trees. The sky itself seems a bit odd in color as well. Compositionally, it might have been better to use a vertical division into thirds, e.g., two thirds tires, one third sky (or vice versa, but since the tires are the subject, I think two-thirds tires.

Walking in the woods
by heida

Comment:
Congratulations on a great shot, and the only true window shot to win (or to win with composition rather than tricks).

AUCKLAND FROM THE DISTANCE
by slonko

Comment:
Good use of the window for framing; nice light. Might have been nice to block the sun further with that angled right frame.