Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like the grain and placement, Good color and good to see the chrome is not blown out at all. 8
Post actions
It has a little noise in the chocolate but very nice and it fits with the title.7
Post actions
i would have voted much higher for this one if it wasn't for the grain. i like the simpleness, the almost monochramatic effect and the composition.
Post actions
Hmmm...I love the composition of this, but the noise/grain is bothersome and really detracts from it.
Post actions
yummy! my kind of breakfast...
Post actions
This is pretty original. The grain gives it something. Cool.
Post actions
It is grainy, but I like the grain in this picture, it gives it interesting texture. This almost feels like a picture in a newspaper...
Post actions
Did you paint the egg? or is that a chocolate shaped egg? the photo is a bit grainy but a good idea!
Post actions
The egg is slightly out of focus....I'd have prefered the egg to be sharpely in focus. good idea. I would have tried to remove the reflection of the egg as well.
Post actions
You could have had removed the noise...
Post actions
Already voted. Comong back for comments:
Post actions
I like the b&w and grainy feel. Tip of the egg is distracting as it's not in focus
Post actions
Too much reflection off the egg.
Post actions
I like the shot, but personally think that the reflection on the egg is a bit distracting. 7
Post actions
Where is the strawberry of the advertisement? :-)
Post actions
Nice picture but too much noise.
Post actions
nice idea, nice egg cup, bit grainy, and the off-centre thing doesn't really work here
Post actions
Awesome shot, pity on all the noice in the photo and also the top of the egg gives the impression as if there was camera shake.
Post actions
nice idea. i would have used other background, for example checked (squared) map.
Post actions
Too noisy!! I dont think it's intended grain. To me the foucs seems on the wire, not the chocolate egg.
Post actions
the grain works in this shot!
Post actions
Post actions
I would have liked to have seen it in color. It really doesnt portray chocolate to me. Im not saying it doesnt meet the challenge. Just saying that the chocolate egg just doesnt look like chocolate in the b/w toned colors.
Post actions
Too grainy, would work better clear and sharp like the strawberry in advertisement.
Post actions
a bit grainy and would of loved it if i couldn't see you
Post actions
The shadows on the chocolate egg distract me a bit. If this was a higher quality shot, this would be an amazing photograph. I really like it, though, even though the quality isn't up to par. 8.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
