Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
A great photograph, but I think the dodging and burning is a bit excessive. Done properly, it should not be noticeable.
Post actions
This image exudes a wonderful atmosphere; I love it! The net nicely balances the centered composition. I'm guessing the background grass was smudged or blurred, an appropriate treatment that works very well here.
Post actions
Lovely image,
Post actions
Whether intentional or not, I like the watercolor look. The highlights are a little overexposed, but very nice composition. 7
Post actions
Pure childhood in a Norman Rockwall scene. It is a perfect image with the possible exception that the grass in the bright area surrounding the boy seems a biot artificial. You should finish very high as it really is an "extraordinary" image.
Post actions
Very nice pose, setting, and lighting. A 9.
Post actions
Looks like Neat Image might have been used for this effect, and it is done very well. A good portrayal of childhood innocense
Post actions
Breathtaking ! The whites are perfect...nothing overexposed. This has that dreamy look that adds so much impact. My first 10 !
Post actions
I just love the lighting and soft focus in this shot.
Post actions
Spectacular image, but the dark ring is more of a distraction than a focusing agent. 8
Post actions
Darkening the outer areas I think would look better if it were more subtle.
Post actions
Very nice soft picture.
Post actions
There seems to be a large circle of highlight dodging that appears a bit overdone. Otherwise, this is very nice. I like the image and the soft focus.
Post actions
Nice image, but I am missing something, maybe some action or a more nostalgic atmosphere. The bright green and the light area around the boy look artifical (not sure whether it actually is), maybe some less bright green would have done it for me.
Post actions
Perfect TEN! I love the pose, the softness, the colors...everything about this picture.
Post actions
Maybe a little more DOF would have helped the eye focus ont he subject
Post actions
Fantastic shot
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
