| Author | Thread | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 10:12:05 PM | 
		| | Put me down for liking take 2 better too! Very cool- you have such a good eye! | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 07:47:12 PM | 
		| | The noise in the first one didn't bother me (at this size anyway) but I definitely prefer the composition of this one.  Well done. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 04:52:14 PM | 
		| | Both shots are good, but the brightness on the second one is a bit too bright, but this is such a pretty image of such a simple object! I like the angle on this image better....both are pretty. 
 | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 03:18:56 PM | 
		| | Great do-over! I like the second one best. It's much more lively. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 02:57:51 AM | 
		| | | Originally posted by pcody: yes. The deep curve adds much more to the flow. Just gotta ask, do you have your camera set to incandescent wb? I love the color.
 | 
 
 The blue in this case is actually done in photoshop.  The wb was set to a preset that I use with my lightbox setup so I would get a more accurate silvery tint of the metal.  The original version of this shot was done with the wb on automatic, so when I tried to adjust the coloring on that it had to go from a yellowish tint to blue, which I think made the noise even worse.
 | 
 | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 02:33:34 AM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/06/2007 02:17:00 AM | 
		| | As long as we're all voting, I very much agree 2 is better with the twisted bend being much better than the "rainbow" bend of 1 and a better angle on the in-focus part. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 10:43:27 PM | 
		| | yes. The deep curve adds much more to the flow. Just gotta ask, do you have your camera set to incandescent wb? I love the color. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 10:42:23 PM | 
		| | I agree the first one is more static. I like the sinuous quality of number 2 better. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 10:29:12 PM | 
		| | door number 2 for me as well! Way more intresting with the composition than the first. I think how the lamp arm comes in and out of the frame makes this photo, well done! | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 10:08:13 PM | 
		| | The second one also get my vote. I love the softness and the blue tones. Most of all I love the detail that you have focused on, as it has such wonderful clarity and deatail, so very rich in that blue colortone. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 10:00:56 PM | 
		| | The second one gets my vote. Good job. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 09:18:03 PM | 
		| | After carefully contemplating...I like take 2. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 06/05/2007 09:18:02 PM | 
		| | Hey, I like the first one, too, but this is great.  Good eye to see the importance of subtle differences.  Nicely done. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
			Home -
			
Challenges -
			
Community -
			
League -
			
Photos -
			
Cameras -
			
Lenses -
			
Learn -
			
			
Help -
			
Terms of Use -
			
Privacy -
			
Top ^
		DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
		
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
		
Current Server Time: 10/30/2025 06:55:35 PM EDT.