| Author | Thread | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/18/2006 07:51:47 PM			 | 
		
		Greetings from the Critique Club: I have been assigned your photo to critique and here are my thoughts:
 
 Personal Reaction: I liked this a lot and it was helpful to see your comments on the photo. With the backwards cap and your bare chest and shoulders, it looks a bit like a swim team photo.
 
 Composition: Good composition; eyes just below center line; face offset; negative space around your head. All these elements seem to work well.
 
 Technicals: Hard to find fault with much. There is a slight halo beside your ear but it’s a minor minor thing. Focus on the eyes is very good.
 
 Conclusions: You were trying for a “whimsical intensity” and you nailed it. Good job!
 
 As always, this is my personal opinion. Feel free to PM me if you’d like further dialog.
  |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
 Comments Made During the Challenge   | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/11/2006 08:57:51 PM			 | 
		
		| Cool!  I like the intense look and the light in your eyes.  But what puts it over the top for me are the freckles. :-) |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/11/2006 04:47:03 PM			 | 
		
		| coming back for a comment, and now I see this pic is worth more than I voted in the first place. bumping up because of your freckles and the pretty b/w! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/10/2006 10:47:57 PM			 | 
		
		| this is spooky yet flavored with nostalgia. how did you make yourself young again? 8 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/10/2006 06:23:29 PM			 | 
		
		| Is 1977 the year you were born in? If so, cool element to use in the photo. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/10/2006 12:06:57 PM			 | 
		
		| Excellent b&w conversion, it really brings out a lot of character very nicely.  Great job! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/09/2006 12:07:30 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/08/2006 11:03:51 PM			 | 
		
		| You nailed the light and there is really good tonal range! Composition is good too. Great work! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/08/2006 02:56:20 PM			 | 
		
		| I like this. The light color of the eyes stands out well. I'm glad you did not go the route of removing all color in the picture except the eyes. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/07/2006 07:42:37 PM			 | 
		
		| Nice lighting. Good use of the frame. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/07/2006 02:36:15 PM			 | 
		
		| did anyone ever tell you, you look like Wayne Rooney |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/07/2006 08:48:18 AM			 | 
		
		| Wonderful.  The best in the group.  I'd try slightly lighter and more contrasty skin tones, but like it as is.  Beautiful work on the eyes. Love the hat. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/06/2006 06:25:22 PM			 | 
		
		| Love your freckles.  It seems just a touch OOF on your face, and more sharp on the embroidery of the hat. I might play with contrast or levels a smidge, but I like the earnestness of it. 7 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/06/2006 03:57:41 PM			 | 
		
		| Great sense of determination and very astute gaze. A well captured image with perfect catchlights. Bump. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/06/2006 09:44:09 AM			 | 
		
		| I love your freckles! Really nice photo. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/06/2006 02:42:49 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/06/2006 12:35:55 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 07:42:37 PM			 | 
		
		| Clarity and focus are amazing.  The BW used here is excellent. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 03:55:15 PM			 | 
		
		| so-so.. lighting is uninspiring on this image. 5 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 06:13:41 AM			 | 
		
		| I would have liked this one more if you had cropped closer to your face :o) good luck |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 02:52:34 AM			 | 
		
		| Cool set up and crop on this one..... |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 01:40:52 AM			 | 
		
		| That would make you 29.  Really nice processing on this.  Great focus on the eyes.  A bit soft yet bullyish. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
11/05/2006 12:31:59 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
			Home -
			
Challenges -
			
Community -
			
League -
			
Photos -
			
Cameras -
			
Lenses -
			
Learn -
			
			
Help -
			
Terms of Use -
			
Privacy -
			
Top ^
		DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
		
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
		
Current Server Time: 11/04/2025 04:34:10 AM EST.