Oh how I wish the sky was not blown on this shot. I think you did a great job of making the tree promonent in the picture. Even with the sky blown I think it deserves a 7.
The overwhelming amount of white-out sky works against this otherwise colorful and appealing subject. This would have worked much better cropped closer to the tree, allowing just enough room beneath it for the part of its reflection that is completely undisturbed. Good luck.
6 - for me would have been 8 or 9 with two things. if you'd got the whole tree in the reflection and if the water had less stuff in it on the reflection. reflections are spectacular when smooth, ordinary when not (for me at least). nice shades of green and the leaves.
Sometimes the trees nearest water change colour first. Yours is an elegant scene. Now if the sky had been a little richer in hue, life would have been that much better ;-)
Stunning image here, and I love the reflection but would have like to see more of it at the borttom as it appears to be cropped a little to tightly at the base of the image. I would have given you top marks if I could have seen the complete portion of the reflection.