Author Thread
Post actions
This is a really nice image! I'm not sure why it bombed.
Post actions
excellent bold color, superior composition, a fine edit. A favorite in this challenge.
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I like the colors, composition and the sky, but the tree looks oversharpened to me on this one.
Post actions
looks over-sharpenned to me. The leaves look funky against the sky...
Post actions
Great. Only thing that would make this pop a lot more was a bluer sky...
Post actions
Not sure what the black line is...it's distracting me a bit. : )
Post actions
Post actions
Looks as too much postprocessing to me
Post actions
You should consider increasing the threshold setting of USM with shots like this. Good luck.
Post actions
Think the poor old fellow has lost the battle - a more apt title could have been "The Survivor"
Post actions
Post actions
nice capture of colors. and good PP on the tree trunk (i assume). 7
Post actions
Very interesting tree and field, which you composed perfectly I must say. Overall I like the processing but would have liked a tad darker blacks and also not have those faint halos in the tree. It's not really noticable except where it contrasts against the darker elements in the background. Maybe just clone that out. Otherwise, great image with good subtle detail throughout.
Post actions
I like the zig-zag of the fields behind the tree, looks like a survivor..
Post actions
EEk - too much saturation on the tree leaves?
Post actions
Love the lush vegetables as a general setting for this fine willow? tree. Overall, a nice image and a location worth revisiting, IMO.
Post actions
Nice tree, composition and setting. But the colors and lighting seem off to me, posibly just over exposed. Might need a bit more contrast and saturation.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
