| Author | Thread | 
		
			|  | 09/09/2006 07:53:30 AM | 
		| | one of my favourite films, excellently portrayed here! well done | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
| Comments Made During the Challenge  | 
		
			|  | 09/05/2006 08:56:07 AM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/05/2006 07:03:05 AM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/05/2006 01:34:48 AM | 
		| | This was a great movie and I like what you've done with it. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/03/2006 03:42:52 PM | 
		| | One of my favorite films.  Not sure how well this works as a 'scene' from the movie, but I applaud your taste in films. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/02/2006 07:55:46 AM | 
		| | really good movie and a really cool concept, points for originality for sure. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/02/2006 07:24:30 AM | 
		| | Isn't it a photo of 2 pictures :)), It is worthless I give U a one with a big O | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/01/2006 02:39:39 PM | 
		| | IMHO this is a good composition but there isn't quite enough light on the subjects faces | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/01/2006 07:31:29 AM | 
		| | Nice...but a little soft.. the photo looks little under exposed.. 6 for me | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 09/01/2006 12:51:12 AM | 
		| | Photographer's notes are hidden until after voting. IMO using the title to slip them in during voting seems a little ...... tacky? I do like the shot, though. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/31/2006 11:44:45 PM | 
		| | Ok got the mirror part but how did you darken the outer area? | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/31/2006 11:23:26 PM | 
		| | Personally, I think your title detracts from the entire image. What's the point of pointing out that it's not a photo? The image itself could be crisper. I think the shadow line across the man's shoulder is a distraction as well. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/31/2006 09:20:35 PM | 
		| | Nicely shot.  I love the darkness to it.  I would have left the title to "Memento".  If someone didn't believe it met the rules, I would have let the Site Council work it out in validation. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/31/2006 07:16:26 PM | 
		| | This movie is awesome! I saw this 3 times in the cinema. You did a great job here I HAVE to rate this 10! | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/31/2006 03:16:40 PM | 
		| | This is a great picture. I'm guessing this took a bit of setup? The low light and black background are very cool. It's almost too clear however for the movie (neither picture that you are imitating is a very clear picture), but that's okay. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 11:47:27 PM | 
		| | Well done, I remembered this scene instantly when I saw shot. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 09:03:47 PM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 07:04:58 PM | 
		| | not familiar with the movie but like the photo ... nice job | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 03:31:42 PM | 
		| | cool shot, but was this actually a scen in the movie? I have seen the movie quite a few times and is one of favorites and I don't remember a photo that just says memento on it. PM if I am wrong. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 01:38:25 PM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 01:09:11 PM | 
		| | hmmm....you must shave a little next time ;o) good picture though. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 12:46:52 PM | 
		| | One of my favorite movies. Decently done, but it doesn't really bring justice to the movie in my opinion. Not bad though. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 12:28:37 PM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 10:04:11 AM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 08:23:33 AM | 
		|  | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 08:15:32 AM | 
		| | Loved the movie and I love your treatment of the poster. You may be getting dinged for it not being an actual scene from the movie but I dont care. You executed this brilliant idea very well (and thanks for the tip in the title - I would have thought her a picture). Bumping up. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 07:12:56 AM | 
		| | well done...glad you pointed out that she was in a mirror, but you should have had validation instead as it would have avoided the title explanation 7 | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 06:45:32 AM | 
		| | Very well done.  I've not seen the film, but this is just like the poster images. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 02:47:59 AM | 
		| | I love this movie! Nicely done. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 02:35:21 AM | 
		| | I want to leave a comment, but don't know what to say... except, cool ! | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 01:27:53 AM | 
		| | Nice going, well-exposed.  Isn't it a shame that you have to defend yourself in the title? | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 01:25:07 AM | 
		| | nice movie poster...unfortunately, the challenge was to replicate a scene from a movie. | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			|  | 08/30/2006 12:34:38 AM | 
		| | Great concept.  Plus 1 for me recognizing it without being bashed over the head by the picture's title, minus 1 for bashing me over the head with the movie title in the picture itself, minus 1 for bashing me over the head by telling me in the title that the girl's in the mirror.  It LOOKS like a photo of two pictures, and the title doesn't correct that. 
 That said, for this movie, a picture of two polaroids is dead on target.
 
 Mush all that around and it lands on a 5.
 | 
 | 
|  Photographer found comment helpful. | 
			Home -
			
Challenges -
			
Community -
			
League -
			
Photos -
			
Cameras -
			
Lenses -
			
Learn -
			
			
Help -
			
Terms of Use -
			
Privacy -
			
Top ^
		DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
		
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
		
Current Server Time: 10/30/2025 09:33:21 PM EDT.