Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow Advanced Edit
Nature Reserved
Fit: DNMC/Unclear 0
These are silhouettes and not shadows but I aqm not sure this is a full-blown DNMC
Aesthetics: Well composed, aesthetically pleasing 2
This is a really good shot even though I do not believe it meets the challenge
Technical: Technically well executed 2
So well captured tonally
Wow: Real impact 2
If I thought that this really met the challenge then I would have scored it much higher.
Total Score = 6
Nice image, I think it would have done better in "Framed" Color is great, I like the silhouette of the trees, but I just don't get the feeling of Shadows.
Very nice picture and a great capture. However I can't help but believe you entered it in the wrong challenge. I see now shadows just silhouettes from the lighting in the background. What a shame I feel this would of done very well in the framing II Challenge.
Is this meant to be in the Framed challenge??? or the Shadow III challenge. I guess either would do but Framed simply leaps into ones mind on seeing this image. It's a great image too.
this is an amzing capture and would have done great in the framing challenge. I would have liked to have had the green color from the light of the buildings deasaturated because my eye keeps gettting drawn to it. just some suggestions I also don't see any shadows, just silhoettes. But I will only take one point off and give you a 7.
This seems to be more about the lightning and sillouhette than shadow. I don't really see a sillouhetted object as being the same as cast shadows. I guess that is nitpicky but this just doesn't work for me for this challenge.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
