Author Thread
Post actions
This is great. True, it probably doesn't make much sense without the title but with it, it's just hilarious.
Post actions
this is great...
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
As a stand alone photo, probably not so great... but a very creative interpretation for this particular challenge. Nicely done. Were there actually roses there? :)
Post actions
I just love the way you have cropped this photograph.
Post actions
Not getting the cliche from the picture.
Post actions
Where is her face? And where is the rose?
Post actions
Well this is a bit of a stretch to fit in the challenge. We don't see any roses or any flowers for that matter. The person could be vomiting or asleep!
Post actions
Nice use of DOF, but I'd really like to see the roses that the subject is smelling. Leaves me wondering just what color they are.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Sorry, but IMHO this photo just doesn't work and here's why: There are not roses (or noses for that matter) in the shot. This person could be throwing up for all we know. Also, there is far too much negative spaces at the top of the image that doesn't seem to serve any purpose.
Post actions
Can't decide if i want to see the rose or not. . .
Post actions
I love this. Very original, creative and great execution. Your border also works wonderfully. Hope it does well!
Post actions
I don't think the crop works here..
Post actions
Well, this represents the stop part, but it would have been nice to see the roses she is smelling. It looks sort of cut off the way it is.
Post actions
HAHAHA i like this. 10 just for originality here. could be lighter and color balance is a bit too blue to me but that may be my screen or your lighting. who cares its bloody original and it got my vote!
Post actions
good use of empty space. i like that you dont actually show the roses. 7.
Post actions
Well I gotta give you credit for being different!
Post actions
I would expect to see roses in a photo with this title.
Post actions
Very brave composition - hope it does well.
Post actions
Technically excellent photo. I do understand the crop, but I'm curious as to why you chose not to show the face and flower in the composition. Just curious, that's in no way a critique.
Post actions
Nice focus and clarity. I see where you were going with the crop, but I think not seeing her face makes the picture feel kind of awkward.
Post actions
wonderful! I love the smack-you-in-the-head subtlety of this.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
