Gorgeous. Very creative use of technology and the subject is ideal for the manipulation as you've done it. I would hang this on my wall, and if I were a member I'd have given you a 10. :)
Very emotional piece, this photo. Your duotones really work to bring out the feelings of loneliness, so in a way, this is one of the best photos I've seen in which duotone wasn't just a choice--it was the right choice. 10
The cool frosty blue hue is perfect for this lonely tree. The white tips of the branches look like a dusting of snow. The composition including the small bush emphasizes the loneliness, and the fence give a feeling of being closed off. The white tips of the tree are balances nicely by the dark blue shadow on the ground - wish the fence post didn;t intersect it. But I really enjoy this pict. 8
Very eerie, reminiscent of ice even with the clear field. I presume from the title you were going for something desolate-looking, in which case you succeeded.
I like the grainy, chilling quality presented here. It looks so much like ice. (though I suspect it was done through IR) Either way, it's well presented and the tone compliments it nicely.
you gambled a little with an artsy presentation and i like it. it looks a little like an ice storm and a little like an infared image. the light and dark layers: sky, distance, midground, and foreground make this a very interesting image. 8
Was this solarization? The tree is highlighted wonderfully and really catches the eye. I dont like the fence in the foreground, maybe if it was less focused or cut out completely?