Removing Comments!!!! - DPChallenge Forums

Sony 16-50mm f/3.5-5.6 E-mount

10/10/2003 12:30:48 PM · #1

One of my biggest complaints with DPC has always been the TROLL comments. I wish we would be able to remove or at least hide the comments that offend us.

I have never before been so offended by someone telling me a photo doesn't meet the challenge or that they don't get the tie in to the challenge as I was when someone was so disrectful to type it all in caps lock. Not only does that signify yelling in the cyber world but it is also rude espeically somewhere like here.

I could care less if they don't like the photo or it doesn't fit the challenge, they can leave that comment anytime they want. Sometimes I will even explain the tie into the challenge to that person in an email. But do we really have to put up with the inconsideration of the trolls who think that is perfectly fine to disrespect everyone and try to prove just how superior they are to everyone else by YELLING there comment?

When will DPC get a box to check that says I don't want any troll comments or at least the ability to hide comments we find offensive. I know this is the cyber world and all but it just isn't right that everytime I look at that photo I should have to see that disrespectful comment in all CAPS!

jmsetzler

Sony Alpha a6000

10/10/2003 12:35:57 PM · #2

That would be a lovely feature... I think that deleting comments that I don't like would be cool :)

10/10/2003 12:39:15 PM · #3

Originally posted by jmsetzler:

That would be a lovely feature... I think that deleting comments that I don't like would be cool :)

Think we should take a photo of this thread for once we are in agreement! LOL

Honestly I took a look at the person's comments and seriously I want to know what she is doing here.

Nikon AF-S Nikkor 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED

10/10/2003 12:45:59 PM · #4

Why does it bother you? Don't let it bother you - be happy & take images ;)

Your images I am sure are not perfect, nobody is, so just relax, go with the flow.

AND AS FOR CAPS, WHO GIVES A MONKEYS? SURLEY YOU HAVE MORE IMPORTANT THINGS TO WORRY ABOUT.

If there is going to be a box saying 'hide my bad comments' then surely we should have one saying 'hide these moaning posts'

Flash

Nikon D700

10/10/2003 12:52:22 PM · #5

Am considering entering a couple of upcoming challenges. Have sent my money for member classification. Have read several postings regarding "trolls". My question is simply: In the member only challenges, can "trolls" leave comments or are these closed to member only submission/voting?

Thanks.

10/10/2003 12:56:10 PM · #6

Originally posted by Flash:

Anyone can leave a comment on any photo in any challenge. Members only challenges can only be voted on by members. There are a lot less troll comments in the members only challenges. I will say that!

10/10/2003 12:59:24 PM · #7

Doesn't following what you say with lots of !!!!!!!!!!!!! mean shouting and rudeness too? :P

Why do you feel the need for a site feature to hide troll comments? Can you not just read them once and then ignore them?

If you really can't do that, and if they are personally attacking you or extremly rude (by this I mean foul language etc) you can ask a site council member to edit or remove the comment, and further action will be looked into against the "troll".

10/10/2003 12:59:47 PM · #8

Originally posted by jonpink:

If there is going to be a box saying 'hide my bad comments' then surely we should have one saying 'hide these moaning posts'

That's why this thread is in rant forum and not a different part of the forum so it doesn't show on the homepage! This forum is to moan so if you don't like the moaning posts don't read it! That's what rant is for to rant or as you put it moan.

Canon EF 24-105mm f/4.0L IS

10/10/2003 01:02:16 PM · #9

Originally posted by Konador:

After checking out the persons comments left so far I am sure it won't be long before site council has to do something. Most of the comments left by her so far were rude. I didn't see a constructive comment in the 30some comments left so far.

zeuszen

Canon EOS-1Ds Mark II

10/10/2003 01:02:44 PM · #10

Defining what's troll and what's not, is the difficult part, I think. To be able to freely delete comments we don't like would result in a very subjective column. I don't think this is, really, what we want or is it?

My choice of dealing with these types of comments is to either ignore or expose them for what they are by briefly commenting myself, after the challenge is over.

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 13:03:50.

10/10/2003 01:04:26 PM · #11

Well, we can't do anything unless someone alerts us, so if something is bothing you please don't hesitate to get in touch via PM.

10/10/2003 01:05:27 PM · #12

No no no I like to read them ;)

Makes me laugh that people can get so up tight about a poxy negative comment.

In my opinion (which suprisingly seems to be the against the norm) we are just so god darn lucky to be able to see and to afford cameras and computers that we can participate in such challenges.

There are many many people in this world who don't have the luxury of flashy didgicams and pc's at home.

Think of them next time you feel 'hard-done by' and it won't matter so much.

I think the trolls are so few and far between that it won't really effect your overall ranking so nowt to worry about. They can't see who shot what image so it's also non personal.

10/10/2003 01:09:55 PM · #13

I'm not talking about negative comments about the photo, I'm talking only about personal and explicit comments such as "You must be a &@$% to think this is good!".

Comments like "THIS PHOTO SUCKS!" aren't actually doing anything wrong, and you just have to learn to live with them.

10/10/2003 01:23:29 PM · #14

Originally posted by jonpink:

Problem is when people look at the photos and comments when searching for a photo in DPCPrints and the negativity and rudeness it turns them off and you loose the sale. Also I use my DPC portfolio to show people some of the photos I have taken, and I recently used it for a job interview by directing them to the portfolio, which proved I was qualified for the position and was also the main reason I got the interview. But would I want a potential employer to see the troll comments? No. My portfolio is now ruined here and that was one of my benefits to the membership, the portfolio. Sad that someone who thinks it is fun to leave undeserved comments can tarnish something so easily.

10/10/2003 01:25:04 PM · #15

You may think it is undeseved, but that brings everything back to the over-said phrase:

"Everyone is entitled to their own opinion"

10/10/2003 01:33:51 PM · #16

Sorry I just think your being silly.

Originally posted by OneSweetSin:

Problem is when people look at the photos and comments when searching for a photo in DPCPrints and the negativity and rudeness it turns them off and you loose the sale.

What person is going to be detered by someone elses opinion? If they like the picture, they like the picture.

Originally posted by OneSweetSin:

Also I use my DPC portfolio to show people some of the photos I have taken, and I recently used it for a job interview by directing them to the portfolio, which proved I was qualified for the position and was also the main reason I got the interview. But would I want a potential employer to see the troll comments? No.

Why not simply print your images and take them with you to the interview, or post a hard copy. It makes you look better anyway.

If print costs are a problem, then there are plenty of free sites that will allow you to post just images.

Originally posted by OneSweetSin:

Sad that someone who thinks it is fun to leave undeserved comments can tarnish something so easily.

Can you share the comments with us? If they are indeed "@"@:!!! words then fair enough, but when you say 'undeserved' it sounds like you think your images are better than anything.

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 13:35:05.

joshua

Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 II

10/10/2003 01:37:58 PM · #17

CAN I GET A BUTTON THAT BLOCKS ALL EXISTENCE OF ONESWEETSIN ON DPC!?!?!

I NEED ONE NOW!!!!!

seriously though, lighten up, sit back and enjoy a good website

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 13:38:31.

10/10/2003 01:48:41 PM · #18

Originally posted by jonpink:

Originally posted by OneSweetSin:
Also I use my DPC portfolio to show people some of the photos I have taken, and I recently used it for a job interview by directing them to the portfolio, which proved I was qualified for the position and was also the main reason I got the interview. But would I want a potential employer to see the troll comments? No.

Why not simply print your images and take them with you to the interview, or post a hard copy. It makes you look better anyway.

I do have a portfolio of 60 photos I take with me almost everywhere, but I can't send all 60 photos with a coverletter and resume in the mail. The portfolio here is just simple to add to my resume the site address and allow them a chance to take a look at here in advance. It really did a lot for me.

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 13:50:41.

joshua

Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 II

10/10/2003 01:52:14 PM · #19

if you start taking pictures people like, this whole "troll" problem will go away

or

you could just except that having differing opinions is a fact of life and dpc is no different

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 13:53:58.

Inga_fang

10/10/2003 01:56:57 PM · #20

When someone calls you stupid, itÂ´s just hurtful and it doesnÂ´t help one to take better photos...take off the caps..if you donÂ´t like the photo...ok...say so in a polite manner, donÂ´t just throw horrible words out there...and as for the person in question...her photos might do with a little help and as for fitting the challenge...she can be way off too

Tokina AF 12-24mm f/4.0 AT-X Pro DX

10/10/2003 02:00:01 PM · #21

Well i think getting upset about a bad comment is stupid.

Beagleboy

Canon EOS-30D

10/10/2003 02:06:57 PM · #22

I just took a look at some of the comments coming from the person that OneSweetSin is referring to. The comments are quite bad and very immature. I really hate to say this and I'm probably going to get hammered for it, but they almost seem to be made by a teen.

I offend people (unintentionally) just by the simple fact of applying regulations and laws that I enforece everyday at work. Some people are also offended that we have the gall to search their luggage. But that's just the way travel is these days. That said, it's a part of life that you will offend people and that some people will offend you.

joshua

Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 II

10/10/2003 02:11:47 PM · #23

too bad most of you weren't here for Clay...now that was a troll...and a particularly funny one at that

Message edited by author 2003-10-10 14:12:09.