Friendship
by Konador

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. I think this does... hard to tell. Exposure composition focus lighting seem good, but again it's hard to tell.

Personal: Interesting, but not enough information to tell what it is- I can't make any kind of emotional connection to the subject.

My vote: 3

Just a simple call away
by guizz

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This is strong. Exposure composition focus lighting all good. I'd prefer a longer DOF so the entire thing is sharp.

Personal: Great idea.

My vote: 6

Simply Elegant
by magnetic9999

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This one does well. Exposure composition focus lighting all good, though I'd like to see the background a little more evenly lit. I think the bright white would make it a bit stronger and more contrasty.

Personal:Yep, very nice.

My vote: 6

A Simpler Time
by QuAcKeR

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This does nicely. The radio itself feels just a tiny bit underexposed (maybe some more light reflected onto the front of it?), but composition focus and lighting in back are all great.

Personal: Yep. Great photo.

My vote: 7

zen garden
by fas-ligand

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This is right on the money. Exposure and focus good. Composition feels quite weak. I feel the lighting should be more diffused to avoid the brights on the rocks.

Personal: This has tons of potential. In my mind more time spent and different compositions could have yielded a better photograph.

My vote: 5

Pill
by CraigD

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This does, but it's not a good photograph. Exposure composition and lighting seem okay... hard to tell with the complete lack of focus.

Personal: I feel this fails to convey.

My vote: 1

Snow on clothes line
by Louison

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. Exposure composition focus lighting all good, I really like the DOF and the capture of the snow falling. At first I accidentally typed "snot falling" :-)

Personal: Very cool. Interesting to look at.

My vote: 6

I'm god of myself
by steo

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This one is perfect for it. Exposure composition focus lighting all very good. The suggested horizon adds depth, but I really wish it was straight.

Personal:Hoo boy I'm guessing that title is gonna get you in some trouble :-) Using the full 640 allowed pixels might have given more detail to the stone, but otherwise I really like it.

My vote: 8

Tibetan bowl
by fanfuine

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This is perfect for it. Exposure composition focus lighting all excellent. I like the DOF this way, but wonder if it would be stronger if the entire thing was sharp.

Personal: Simply simplicity. Nicely done.

My vote: 8

Who needs calculators?
by mquesnel

Comment:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge. This one is a great idea. Exposure composition focus lighting all very good.

Personal: Using the full 640 pixels allotted would have allowed more exploration of the focus detail.

My vote: 5