Reaper's Liquor
by puya

Comment:
To me this looks overprocessed...
TC

10D: a Self-Portrait
by kirbic

Comment:
Are you taunting me? Nice sharp main image. IMHO the OOF circle is a little disracting and maybe not necesary.
TC

Black Water
by lizzyc3

Comment:
The water ain't black, the surroundings are. Nice image, inaccurate title?
TC

The Rose
by Marjo

Comment:
Looks overexposed or overprocessed. My first thought was not black, but blue...
TC

Me and My Shadow
by Rasai

Comment:
From the Critique Club

With no photographers comments, I am not sure what you were attempting to achieve with this photo.

I will say that this shot seems to suffer from a lack of focal point, both technically (nothing in focus) and compositionaly (too many distractions) however, I don't really know what you were attempting to convey with this image.
TC

Gerbers
by shareinnc

Comment:
Just a question, why B/W?
TC

Stick for Lips
by bjallen

Comment:
With these subjects and the amount of grain in this shot I can tell what is not if focus, but I can't really tell what is in focus...
TC

Lonely
by loboz33

Comment:
Very nice image with a big ugly border.... However, your DOF does not appear to be very shallow. In fact, this would fit much better in a soft focus challenge!
TC

Watching Otter Antics
by banditis53

Comment:
Your DOF here does not appear to be shallow...
TC

Icicle
by rickhd13

Comment:
I can not tell if this shot has shallow DOF or not as I only see two focal planes, one in focus and one not...
tTC