Breakfast at our House
by alexjack

Comment:
This one should have rated higher in the challenge. I voted an 8, wanted to rate higher but the blue tint held me back. This was one of the better ideas for "morning". I really wish more people could have seen that. You still came out with a great should and you should be proud of that. It was a brilliant idea. (no blue tint next time though LOL )

Necessary Measures
by JeniY

Comment:
I am shocked this didnt place higher!

B-R-I-G-H-T and early
by heavyj

Comment:
Personally, I think this one was under rated and should have done better in the challenge. Even though I didnt care for the "high key". ;) I am shocked that it didnt place higher than some other photos.

The Divide
by Dudski

Comment:
nice lines, color and overall balance. I think you captured a great shot. maybe a tad bit of contrast is needed in the streets. great job and good luck

And the world is safe for another day
by Wenders11

Comment:
technically, i like the photo. I am really torn on this one though, because when I vote for challenges, I really take into HIGH consideration the Title of the challenge (which everyone should) and in this case the title is "Evening".
I think it's a great image. I think it will do well in the challenge. Its nice to see something besides lakes and sunsets (no offense to those who submitted those)
Best of luck to you.

Late Evening Blues
by TomCubis

Comment:
my favorite photo for this challenge and my only 10. good luck, this deserves to place in the top 3

Bathtime balloon bribery
by Sinky

Comment:
i personally cant believe that you submitted this image for a challenge.

Dinnertime
by everclear25

Comment:
Technically it's a good capture. On my screen though, it looks like there was a lot of cloning and healing used, mostly on the right side of the image. I can see brighter spots and lines where there shouldnt be any. My monitor is calibrated so it picks up a lot of things.
Okay, now onto the scoring side. I have said this about 20 times already during this challenge and I will say it again here. The title of the challenge is "Evening". What does this have to do with Evening in your opinion because I don't get it. It doesnt look like Evening

Associated Press
by debapaka

Comment:
I get where you were trying to go with this image but it just didnt work out, in my opinion. good luck to you.

Fading away
by sunita

Comment:
I think its a good shot. It is blown out way too much on the left though. But that's not why I am giving a low score. When I vote on challenges, I really take the Subject of the challenge into high consideration, as everyone should.
The challenge was "Evening" and I don't find anything about this shot to be categorized in "evening".
Even the title of the shot leads as far away to the challenge as the image itself.
I think it would have been better for you to submit this image for a different challenge and also work on the levels and curves if you do.
I am curious to hear why you submitted this particular shot for a "Evening Challenge"