light as feathers
by shutterfly

Comment:
This is a beautiful photograph. I can't vote on this challenge but I am sure it will receive high marks from those who can. Very nice.

Zen
by mbardeen

Comment:
I can't vote on this challenge, but if I could, this would be a 10 from me. Beautiful framing, composition and theme. I don't see a single thing about it I don't like. Nicely done.

Webmaster
by autool

Comment:
EW! So detailed it gives me the creepy-crawlies.

Round and round
by pncowley

Comment:
It's a beautiful shot of a sunrise, but the wheels, rather than being the focal point (as they should be for this challenge), sort of get lost in the shadows.

RedRound
by MikeO

Comment:
A nice idea for a circle, but I don't like the reflection in the paint. You at least should have worn a darker shirt so it wouldn't be quite so noticeable.

Twilight
by PHOTOCHlX

Comment:
I don't care for the effect of the lighting. I imagine you are going for that being the focus of the shot, but to me, it's distracting and, with so many of them, it loses its effect.

Fun night on the town with my Grandchildren.
by jimsapp

Comment:
A nice firework shot.

Illuminated by Fireworks
by alanfreed

Comment:
This is kind of cool because you chose to focus on the crowd rather than the fireworks themselves. My eye is drawn to the child in the front center of the picture since his face is just a bit lighter than the boy sitting closer to the camera. It's a shame he wasn't lit a little better since his body language and facial expression speak for the rest of the crowd.

Textures at night
by TopQ

Comment:
This is an interesting abstract and well done dark-on-dark, but I don't think it fits this challenge very well at all. It does nothing to suggest night on the town, even stretching the definition of the challenge. I do like the blue in the top left and the fact that you were able to capture your textures despite very limited lighting.

Old Cascade Theater, Renovated
by sunflower

Comment:
This is a bit too much out of focus. I wish you had been able to get all of the lettering readable. I do like the colors and placement on the page.