Enchanted BC
by zeuszen

Comment:
Picture has moved from the realm of photography. Too little detail in the photo. I know it is what you were trying for, but the biggest detractor is that yellow shape over their shoulders, I spend too much time thinking it is a big kite that has landed on them. Or maybe some kind of Pterodactyl.

Scenic Southwest Oklahoma
by postoakinversion

Comment:
Beautiful picture. The pastels in the picture really make it seem to be so inviting. Did you try to use the shadows in PS to bring up some of the colors of the flowers in the foreground? Would love to see those yellows be bright. However, I still love the picture.

Petco Park
by thelsel

Comment:
Good colors on this capture. The blowouts on the signs/lights is a shame, but is totally understandable with the capture. I do think the exposure is spot on for the field.

Columbia River Gorge NSA
by bmatt17

Comment:
The colors in this picture are just beautiful. Great capture. You may get docked for it being soft, but I think it is almost perfect.

NYC
by JPR

Comment:
Beautiful picture. sky does seem a bit fake to me, don't really know why, did you do some extensive burning on it? The other thing that seems to distract from the photo to me is that one vertical light toward the left of the photo, seems to be such a harsh break between light and dark, and so it continually draws my eye from the rest of the beautiful picture.

Street Shopping
by Kavey

Comment:
While this picture may not be the most expected photo for a challenge, it is definitely one that I would see in a travel book. I do like the semi-repetitive pattern in it. Also filling the frame with the shirts works very well. It does seem like it could be just a little sharper.

Windmill at the open air museum in Bokrijk Belgium.
by Patje46

Comment:
The subtle doubling of the windmill blades(?) in the breaks between the leaves, makes this photo really jump out at me. The fence as well adds to the general pleasure of looking at the scene. Only detraction which I would clone out is the shadow on the road (being real nitpicky, the airplane trail in the sky as well). Both are really minor things, but I think this should do very well in the challenge. Bumping up another point after looking at it for a second time.

Market Street
by banmorn

Comment:
This is my choice for the best photo in this challenge. If it doesn't score high, we need to have our heads examined. The architecture, combined with the lighting, combined with the reflections of the sky just makes it stand out far and above the other photos. GREAT JOB!

Gold at the waterfront
by johnmk

Comment:
Great capture of the rainbow, but it is inconsistent and overpowers the real beauty of the boats and buildings.

Bellevue at Dawn
by Chaszmyr

Comment:
seems like it needs a tad rotated clockwise