Invisibly Transparent
by joezl

Comment:
Maybe a little silly, but why would the bottle have a cap on if there is a cap to the side?

The image is well composed, but it might be nice to have seen the edges of the bottle (even really faintly), though I suppose that was for the 'transparency' part of the challenge... (-:

Clear indulgence
by dmmonty

Comment:
I like porto, and the distorted bottle is really clear and has an interesting shape, but perhaps a colour other than orange/yellow could have been chosen for the backgroud? It's so bold, it almost overpowers.
nitpick: way off to the left by the border there seems to be a little extra line (missed when cloning out??)

Samara
by kiwiness

Comment:
wow. creepiness. Tthe colours of the place for some reason make me think of a church, which makes it doubly so. I don't know if it was possible with the pic, but personally I would have liked to see a bit lower of a crop (more desk/computer), as I think the top third of the image is a bit distracting rather than aiding the overall picture. (-: -7

Merced River
by bryanbrazil

Comment:
This has beautiful colours and great clarity. I don't know if you tried flipping the image, but to me (holding my computer upsidedown), it's a bit more intriguing that way, and I think either way it's hard to miss that it's a reflection.. (-: -7

Rainbows
by Flash

Comment:
I love the way you really brought out the colours of the rainbows here. They're incredible. I don't know if it's due to that, but the sky is really purple, which looks a bit odd to me. And I find the dark bottom to be really heavy, almost overpowering the rainbow's brilliance. (-: -6

My Son, the Poet
by mannjudit

Comment:
I'm glad that someone put a picture of a guy in here too... being a little tired of only girls being 'delicate'... though i don't really think that all the motion blur adds that much to the pic.

Open ..up
by tfarrell23

Comment:
This is a beautiful image, though i would have loved to see more of the rose (and maybe less of the blue). -7

The Old Southwest
by AzCKelly

Comment:
I really like this image, but I htink it could be enhanced if it was a bit lighter, with a bit more depth to the shading and tone.

Soft
by PollyBean

Comment:
I like how the graininess adds to the 'softness' of the photo, though i find that the angle of the branch seems to sorta push the flower head down, giving the whole picture a bit of a 'sad' or 'weighed down' look.

Vertical sky
by bpickard

Comment:
A very bold and interesting image, though I don't know that i find the grain adding to what is otherwise a very modern, sharp picture.