Empty Reflection
by De Sousa

Comment:
Creative interpretation! I love the way you weave the black wire through as a hint that there's something not quite ordinary about this "reflection". Here's a timeline of my reations for your amusement:

"What the...?!? How is that black line not reflecting?... Wait a minute... (read the title again)... There's nothing in the bottom glass... but you can't photoshop an important element like that out... hold on, that doesn't look like an exact reflection of the glass... Hmmm... (studied the line for a bit)... Oh! That's not just one glass!! There's no real surface relection! You devilishly tricky photographer!!

Great Shot! Perhaps you should recreate this for the misunderstanding challenge :P

X
by levyj413

Comment:
Wow! An X for you indeed! Were you thinking of this composition when you took the shot or did this come to you later while editing? Either way, this is brilliant!

Ode to Harold
by hyperfocal

Comment:
I wonder if this is another awesome IreneM shot. If not, it's worthy of her awesome drop shots. This is SO 10 I wish there were a knob that went up to 11. Great photo.

holding what you cannot reach
by posthumous

Comment:
Touching photo (pun intended). If I made a wild guess I would say this is a window reflecting some outdoor features and the hand is inside the window. This is an excellent creative interpretation of the challenge to make texture with the reflection rather than making it the subject. I hope this does well but I fear some may not take the time to think about it.

Positive Reflection
by tsikakis

Comment:
Interesting processing choices. I wonder how this would feel if the left edge of the mirrow were straightened... (trying it out)... Yea, the balance feels better to me that way, but that might just be me.

Underworld
by RKT

Comment:
Very interesting organic feel.

Ice Sculpture of a Pioneer - reflecting coloured lights
by Shaman

Comment:
This is really creative & it's nice to see frozen water amist all of the boring old melted water most entries have. High marks for that and not letting the whites get too out of control/blown out. The green light on the chest draws my attention from his face and I wish the interesting colors drew me towards his facial features instead. nIce compostion overall :P

Kung Hei Fat Choi!
by Gordon

Comment:
Happy new year! And an abstract new year it is too! If white is the subject of this shot, then you have followed it to perfection. You are indeed panning, which is more than I can say for many other shots in this challenge.

Cat Scratches
by pointandshoot

Comment:
There's certainly motion blur going on and this composition works on some levels. It would help for me if there were some element of the subject that was sharp. Otherwise it looks like a shot where everyting is in motion rather than trying to track along with the subject.

Board & Sun set
by shohel78

Comment:
I don't see the panning, unless you're going to argue that you're tracking these two boats with the motion of the Earth and the sun is blurring along in the background. If that's the case, this would have been more effective with stars and a long exposure night shot (and just a little lighting on the boats). It is a nice picture. I really like the overall composition.