Cloves
by bobonacus

Comment:
Interesting shot. I had given it a 3 at first but over a second view it deserves a higher score of 4. I wish there was a subject sticking out from the rest of the photo.

Bombarded
by jimness

Comment:
Moon pictures are really hard to take. Especially in perfect focus. You've done better than I but the shot really still doesn't work for me. Kind of wished it was a bit less blury. Nice try and keep taking shots of the moon.

Puzzled
by elizadeb

Comment:
Interesting texture. Nothing really eye catching and it does seem noisy. I believe the border does help this shot a little.

"Marble" a metamorphic rock
by bob_bobski

Comment:
Looks like crinkled paper? Well recreated but the photo really has nothing eye catching for me. The texture seems very uninteresting.

Rough Path
by DigitalElph

Comment:
Interesting DOF but I would have much preferred to see a different angle on this one. The upper half of the picture really does nothing for this one. Maybe even having the DOF much closer to the camera.

Hide and Seek
by pollypanda2000

Comment:
Seems very pixilated and not sharp. However interesting to see you got a shot when you got the cat peeking out from behind the broom.

Moonrise
by Camabs

Comment:
if this shot is of the moon then I know how hard they are to take. It looks more like a fruit being processed in B&W but the noise is way too high in this shot and the focus is very soft where there is actually any definition(the lighter colored area.) The darker area has no real definition and it seems pointless to focus there imo.

Pilings
by tvsometime

Comment:
The shot just doesn't do anything for me. THe background seems more distracting than anything else and the subject doesn't seem intriging. It's a little soft as well.

Those Peelin' Red Blues
by surlybiff

Comment:
This shot although it meets the challenge does nothing for me. Nothing spectacular about it.

Rough and smooth.
by David Newland

Comment:
Nice shot. I originally gave this a 3 and I don't know why looking at it again it's a 6 for sure. Very sharp and well done.