Basketweave
by Phonic Monkey

Comment:
Composition: Good symmetrical view of the weave. Nice touch with the one strand slightly out of place. A lower perspective I believe would provide a little more sense of depth. 8
Exposure: Due to the shininess of the strands it seems a bit over exposed and the bright spots a little distracting. 6
Impact: Above average. The pattern of the weave is interesting and draws the viewer into the image though with a lower perspective I think more impact could be achieved. 6

Overall: 7

Smith Mountain Lake Sunset
by SJCarter

Comment:
What works: tonality of the entire image and the definition in the water and sky.
What doesn't work: the colour and the centered horizon (band of dark trees)

Message edited by author 2005-07-19 15:33:57.

Smith Mountain Lake Sun Rays
by SJCarter

Comment:
What works: low horizon to emphasize the drama in the sky
What doesn't work: The brightest part of the clouds are blown out therefore distracting from the nice beams of light protruding them.

Struggle for the ball
by zdanielr

Comment:
Excellent action shot. Even though it's stop action there is a sense of movement. Well done.

No Time for Sports II
by shot

Comment:
I'm trying to see the connection with the challenge topic here. Maybe this is a sports watch though the description does say to catch the action and action does not appear to be portrayed here. Could be that it's too dark so some of the details have gone missing.

Rara Avis
by srbrubaker

Comment:
Very good high key effect. The head seems to be OOF while the body is in focus. Slightly more DOF I think is needed. 9

Freeloading Visitor
by glad2badad

Comment:
Cute capture however appears to be oversharpened.

I Can Fly Anywhere! Wheeeeeee
by typologic

Comment:
Cute, but overprocessed.

Fisherman at Dusk
by Bear_Music

Comment:
The composition seems to work and the exposure seems ok (maybe just a little under) however the colours seem weird.

Leader of the Pack
by rookie92

Comment:
Good perspective, colour, exposure and composition however I feel that just a little more DOF is needed to provide just a tad more definition in the trailing riders.