The Picture of Dorian Gray
by bdenny

Comment:
This is an excellent image, all about "feel" and mood. As such, it got voted down...

Behind the Law
by g14n

Comment:
I liked this shot. Here desat actually tells a message, with blue being the universally accepted color of the police, and thus the law. I scored this an 8 because of I appreciate the effort to have a meaningful image. Unfortunately, what probably brought it down is that compositionally it does not have much going on, with not only the cops but also everybody else having their backs to the camera.

fighting gravity
by Skip

Comment:
Let me subscribe - great image and one of my favorites in the challenge. You got a 9 from posthumous and that sealed your fate :-)

A Brick in the Wall
by BakerBug

Comment:
OK, this is either a 4 or a 10. Can't decide... Still can't decide... OK, it's not a 10, but it is a good score from me nevertheless.

Colorful Refection
by karenk

Comment:
Hey, cool idea! How about two more: ALL the reflection in color, or maybe the real horse in color and EVERYTHING EXCEPT the horse in color in the reflection?

Fading Away
by Rob O

Comment:
Excellent composition - pretty much perfect!

tomorrow's landscape?
by sidpixel

Comment:
Powerful image - well done.

Art of the Weld
by LaMas

Comment:
Original choice of subject, and well-done desat.

The Shore
by bjaz34

Comment:
This is a very nice idea, but I think that in order to make your point you oversaturated the blue in the water. Would have preferred the contrast to come from a darker and more contrasty B&W conversion on the shore.

på väg
by xantangummi

Comment:
Good image - don't appreciate the non-english title.