Turning to the Wind
by whitewolf

Comment:
Not sure about the processing of the windmill here.

Reflections of Narnia
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Not sure what Narnia has to do with the Four Elements and not sure why you went for this title. Perhaps a more fitting title would do the image more justice in this challenge. It is an impressive image and well processed, I just fear that some might score your image lower due to the lack of relevance to the challenge category. 9

Summer Evening by the River
by MaryO

Comment:
I imagine the full size image would look fantastic. I think that you have lost some of the brilliance of this in the resizing, which does not deserve lowering your score. 9 for me.

Harnessing Wind and Water
by Bruce_the_Robert

Comment:
A bit more contrast would make this image POP. Nice shot, just lacks the pop it could have for me. Well done. 7

Shapely
by Brin

Comment:
Voted on 36 Percent of photos so far and this is my favourite image by a long shot so far. 10 IMO

furrows
by sidpixel

Comment:
Nice work. For a Basic Editing Challenge, the only thing that I could comment on for the downside of this image is the composition. Perhaps symmetry would have made this slightly better, but isn't worth voting lower on. 10

Smoke
by d_pan1

Comment:
Fantastic Image. 10

Two Lives, Overlapping
by meyers

Comment:
Looks slightly out of focus to me. Was this done hand held.

tick tack unstop
by alwin_tanas

Comment:
Noisy and underexposed IMO Very Grainy in the face of the clock. Better lighting would have improved this image a bit. Better positioning would also improve the overall quality. At present it sits high and right of centre, with no apparent need. Good Luck

Shadow in the Squares
by DarrellGraves

Comment:
Looks like one of the images that you can stare at for hours and something will appear. Nice work