Round Momentum
by Jaxson

Comment:
Better lighting would have actually communicated round. As it is, it depends on me knowing what this is, and/or the title. I do like the blurred effect of the ball in motion. Might have been a better shot (as it is) for speed.

Brown Eyed Girl
by Chiqui

Comment:
I don't like the title, given that it's in B&W, and I don't like the eyes looking away, since that detracts from the roundest parts of the eye. The photo's OK, but doesn't really grab me. It's a little too soft for me.

Round²
by mbardeen

Comment:
Great use of a "flaw" in your teleconverter (I'm making a giant leap of faith there!). Wish I had thought of it. My only concern with it is the blur at the edges - too bad it couldn't be sharper. I like the colors and lighting (that shadow in the middle is excelent). Focus is good. Overall a nice shot and a great idea.

Growing Sphere of Influence
by adine

Comment:
Why wasn't this in Unanswered Questions - cause I got a lot of them right now! Very interesting shot. Unfortunately some of my questions are technical - why B&W? Why are there ferns in the background? I want to like it more, because the subject is so interesting, but the picture itself isn't quite working for some reason.

Illusion - Side to Side
by Musicman

Comment:
I'm really interested to find out what the title means. The focus is good, DOF is great, light is about just right. Color and sharpness could maybe be a little better for me, but it's somewhat subjective - I can see the appeal in it.

Hidden Foundations
by eloise

Comment:
Crop the bottom by 10%, and rotate about half a degree counter clockwise, and this would have gained a point.

Record
by skiphilkah

Comment:
A second light source would have lightened the shadows a little - they're a bit too stark for me. And your existing light source is a little harsh.

Blue like water
by KissakiMan

Comment:
Hey, Culligan Man! ;-) A more sqare crop would have worked better to accentuate "round" to me. And while I joked about the Culligan logo, the writing at the bottom is a bit of a distraction. But I like the color, the focus is well enough on the bottom of the bottle, the dimples or droplets are a nice effect, and the DOF works well.

Self Portrait #2/ Contact Lens
by BobsterLobster

Comment:
The tone is interesting, and the image is sharp. I think that it would have been better to have positioned yourself without the distracting reflections in your eye. The curves of your eye do make for an interesting take on "round". And I like the way the border sort of fades out of the left-top portion of the shot.

Well Rounded Pleasure
by cmrk74

Comment:
They look more square than round. Composition is good, and I like the DOF. I'm not wild about the lighting. I'd have liked the front to be a little less dark and shadowy.