The Guardian
by Beagleboy

Comment:
Something givess the impression of being astray here - it seeems tilted, but it isn't when you look closely - I guess just not taken from directly head on. This does highlight a problem with this challenge though - to me, a centred composition absolutely requires a strong graphical element to an image, which this has with those curved shadows and pointing lines - but those graphical elements have to be very regular. Good detail here, though that direct light has lost you some element of texture and perhaps mystery from the scene. 6

seven
by slonko

Comment:
Having gone to the trouble of making that asymettrical border, it might have been an idea to use levels just to take the black in the image all the way to absolute black. Good detail and light, especially the fading away toward edges. One of the better flower portraits here. 6

On Any Windy Sunday
by jimmythefish

Comment:
Gentle halo-ing around the subject is effective in drawing and keeping the eye there, cntred composition used efffectively for once: isolating from background, and illustrating the height of this jump. Good work. 6

Lost Childhood
by Neuferland

Comment:
Difficult balance to achieve between concentration on this old pushchair and a suitable sense of isolation. Seems like quite a lot of sharpening has gone on - has that brittle, fine pixelation. I quite like the shot, but it isn't completely getting through to me. 5

The eye of God (Just a title)
by cimarron98

Comment:
One of remarkable few images so far to display an understanding of the requirements graphically of a centred composition. There is a problem for me in the overall sense of lack of clarity - the eye itself is so comparatively dark that it is difficult to fix my eye on any detail there. I think perhaps some dodging/burning work might have helped the balance of brightness in the shot. 5

Headache Ball
by Drake

Comment:
Exceptionally sparse composition, though i think you could have afforded to brighten the whole thing to a greater extent: your sky is only mid-grey, and absolutely featureless - might have had more impact if you had taken this closer to a silhouettte. Perhaps what will most let your score down is that this is not really an image suited to a centred composition, you've just cropped it that way. 3

The Final Drop
by silverleaf

Comment:
Small image, and even then appears to lack detail and clarity. Appears focussed, but nevertheless has an impression of not being in focus. 4

scrap
by jus6681

Comment:
Graininess gives a certain photojournalistic quality, especially with the vignetting. get a sense that there might have been some fascinating textures available here, but that you may have wiped them out a little with that level of contrast. 7

Self Reflection
by t_online

Comment:
There's a sense of liquidity in the flesh around the eye that is both rather distracting and rather unpleasantly death-like, especially in the desaturated colour. I find it unappealing, I'm afraid. Doesn't say anything to me. 3

Guggenheim Museum
by lpnyc

Comment:
I'm not sure this isn't th most profoundly obscure and surreal submission I've ever seen. Not only does the actual image not relate to the subject, but the image that the comments refer to also doesn't meet the challenge.