River Reflections
by Spanish_Grease

Comment:
This is a beautiful landscape. From the looks of this over-all, I think it's quite good in many ways. I hesitate to share my opinion on this simply because I'm sure it is as you want it to be, and it is good.
My preference would be to add just a little more contrast to help with the dark snow on the bottom, and to add a little more saturation to make the sky brilliant so it isn't just another sunset. I'm giving this a 7, which is a pretty good score. The overall shot just looks a little flat to me. I do love the composition.

Liquid Logic
by jmsetzler

Comment:
This is so crisp and clean. The detail in the drops of water is phenomenal. My only negative comment on this, knowing it will show my ignorance. I do not know what it is! So, it lacks a little interest for me. I am still rating this quite high, I still think of and clearly see "water" as I view this. 9

Uniquely Designed By Nature
by EddyG

Comment:
I cannot even imagine what went into this shot. I am looking forward to seeing your notes on how this was done. 10

Water Colors
by jjbeguin

Comment:
This is one of my favorite shots in this challenge. My only suggestion is the crop feels a little tight on the top, but I don't know if you are trying to hide something in the way. Beautiful work, beautiful color. 10

Water & Ice
by oskar

Comment:
This is just so serene. I love the frozen grass, it gives stability and dimension to the shot. Awesome effect. 10

Wahconah Falls
by roo

Comment:
This is quite a beautiful scene. I am wondering why you didn't want to show this in color.

Flow
by TooCool

Comment:
This is simply spectacular. It is my favorite of the challenge. I love the red rocks.
When shooting water movement I find it critical to pick the right shutter speed for the ideal effect. You managed to hit it perfectly here. 10

Cube and Spots
by oskar

Comment:
This is so perfect for this challenge!
My only suggestion is; the clarity of the dots is a little soft or something to me.
I think if you utilized the allotted file size it might help this out.
You are only at 46,979 bytes and you can go up to 150,000 bytes.
You might play with the compression a little and max it out in future challenges to improve the clarity of your shots. It still gets a 9 from me. :)

Light Simplicity Bright Electricity(ala Edison)
by Mona

Comment:
This is an awesome photograph! I think it's just a bit busy and a little technical for a "simplicity challenge." However, as lighting goes, you did capture the essence of simplicity. I'm giving this a 7

colours
by imagesloyola

Comment:
This is so great! The colors are bright, the subject is simple. 10