Aluminum Foil Star
by indianzfan

Comment:
The star isn't the tacky part its the paperclip. Good touch!

Hang in There
by jpb323red

Comment:
LOL you could use that for the tackiest Christmas Decoration, too. I have one of those ornaments too but it won't stay in one spot it keeps moving. =o) Thanks for the smile.

Please......Post Our Bail?
by ddmckinney1954

Comment:
Very cute kitties, seems to have a bit to much gold in your whitebalance. I gave you a 7 though cause the photo does show emotion to the point it is moving.

Count Your Blessings
by librodo

Comment:
Very touching photo. Makes for wonderful photojournalism also. 10 for the emotion!

Bulletts
by lmatranga

Comment:
Critique Club

This image is just lacking in lighting, it throws the whole thing off. Also, you have two bullets in good focus, two slightly softer, then that first one on the left is just to far out of focus. Something you may not have thought is the normal person reads from left to right. Even when looking at photos the eye looks from the left to right of the photo, so of course first thing you see is that out of focus bullet and it just ruins the rest of the image.

As for meeting the challenge I am the wrong person to answer that as I personally have a big dislike for anything related to guns. I don't believe it to meet the challenge as guns are anything but simple, however to others they would feel it meet. I would say work on the lighting and you could get a good photo out of this.

Old Red Barn
by Remington

Comment:
Critique Club

Very nice definately fits the challenge well has a very simple feeling to it. I'm not sure if it is the clouds swirl that is distracting but I feel like I am in Kansas and waiting for the twister to touch down and pick up the barn at any minute. No matter what though it is a good photo and you did well with it. Just think the clouds took it from simple to where you are looking for for more.

My first set of wheels
by lilnukee

Comment:
8 for cuteness but a minus one for not getting the entire tractor in the photo. Still a 7. Very cute

M V Waipa Delta River Boat
by train

Comment:
Its a nice photo but I can't help but wonder how it would look in sepia tones.

Mandolin
by wkmen

Comment:
Critique Club

It does make for a very interesting and appealling entry in the shapes challenge. The lines and curves are very appealling. Your only downfall are the strings are slightly soft. This is definately a very nice relaxing photo and well done.

Ordinary Shelves in a New Light
by jaimeegrl

Comment:
Critique Club

As for shapes it does meet the challenge but the photo lacks depth and demension, its just to flat. The only shadow visable isn't balanced out and appears to be lost in the black. It does make for a decent abstract even with its faults.