finally a break in the rain
by FourPointX

Comment:
Without a strong subject your composition lacks interest, though you have successfully captured some interesting clouds.

Over the City
by epescala

Comment:
Wonderful, though the one dark cloud seems overpowering and unbalanced. Just bad luck. A nice composition well exposed.

The Ides of March 7:14 AM
by hahn23

Comment:
Good golly, what a scene! There's so much interest here it hurts. A few small criticisms- much too dark and contrasty for my taste, the foreground tree distracts, and did you shoot this with the widest lens you had, because, wow what a scene. I don't know what was going on to your right, but if you could have moved over and lowered your camera to bring those foreground rocks more into play it would really have make this incredible.

Florida Sun
by bjoern

Comment:
I think I might have gone with more water and less sky since the detail in the sky is less interesting even than the foreground. That would have made the silhouetted portion more dominant and therefore more interesting.

hOle
by mefnj

Comment:
A striking composition, albeit an unconventional landscape. I also see possibilities for non-negative and landscape format compositions (especially with such mirror perfect reflections).

Carpe Diem
by JuliBoc

Comment:
A little brighter and you would have had a subject. I little darker would have made a silhouette. You got caught in the middle.

PeriwinkleSunrise
by dali_lama_2k

Comment:
I applaud your attempt to create a bokeh effect with the sunrise, but your subject isn't quite strong enough IMO, and your exposure is a bit dark overall. Perhaps if you'd gotten a little closer the shells to bring out their interesting detail.

Into the sun
by Lawton

Comment:
No subject and little detail in the sky. Did you use a tripod?

Intrepid Sunset
by tvsometime

Comment:
Unlike many others in this challenge, you have succeeded in creating interest in your foreground by using it as a silhouette against a very dramatic sky. Nice creativity and balance.

Introduction to Olbers' Paradox
by Venser

Comment:
I had to look it up on the internet, and I'm still not sure how to apply it to your photo. In any case, we're only dealing with one star here, and it is nicely placed to create an interesting silhouette of your skyline.