Dark Past Close
by facesastheycome

Comment:
The noise really hurts this shot. I'm also stuck trying to figure out what the subject is.

Dude Pleases Cameras
by saintaugust

Comment:
Wonderful job with the selective desat! I really like the mixed effect of the grass near the steps.

incoming
by darksky

Comment:
Hello from the Critique Club!

This shot definitely has that wow factor that grabs your attention. The sky is very ominous and it strikes me not as a negative, but as a late evening sky that is about to produce the most horrific storm ever seen. The airplane's colors add to the tension of the shot, as it looks quite sinister with the dark nose and bright windshield.

I very much like how the airplane is in the lower portion of the frame as it reinforces the idea that it is about to land. This also gives good balance between the plane and the orange part of the sky. I don't care for the light post. It is much to prominent in this shot and does steal some attention from the airplane and sky. It might have been better if you had moved a few steps to the left so as to make the light post the right edge of the frame. However, doing this may have ruined the angle you had on the airplane. Having the plane coming right at the viewer is one of the key elements that make this such a powerful shot. So maybe a few steps closer would have helped.

Overall this shot is quite good and is definitely one of the more memorable shots in this challenge. ...And congratulations on your best entry so far!

-Bill

Duh Pinchy Code
by LevT

Comment:
Great idea and well done! Hope the text doesn't get you DQ'ed.

Come Ride With Me
by Arcanist

Comment:
I feel like this is cropped too close. The clean lines of the bike are broken by the edge of the frame.

Ursa Major
by OdysseyF22

Comment:
This is a really good shot! The stars are nice crisp points. I hope the voters recognize that is really tough to get. (at least it is tough for me)

The Falls
by I Enjoy Ham

Comment:
B&W works wonderfully for this shot!

bridge over dirty water
by Jaded_Housewife

Comment:
This is one of my favorites in this challenge! Good luck!

Twilight
by rayg544

Comment:
Is the green cast from a street light? Very erie!

Wrong Book?
by srichmond

Comment:
Not sure I understand your title. Why is that the "Wrong Book"?