Publishers Monthly: "Author of the Year"
by sfarrell23

Comment:
Interesting idea... I think it works, though it bothers me how the top left corner starts to get blurry. Otherwise I think it is a simple idea that could possibly be used for a magazine cover.

US News & World Report
by pnicholls

Comment:
Gorgeous use of this type of photo. Excellent example. I'm not sure it really fits the magazine, but it's very well done. I think it could be the cover of a magazine just not necessarily the one you picked. beautifully done though!

Going Green Gazette
by cloud9

Comment:
Hmmm... not sure I really care for this or think it fits... not familiar with the magazine, but I don't think it would work. I just don't think this is a very effective photo.

Home and Design
by sher

Comment:
Wow very pretty, if this is your house, this is really cool, congrats! I think this would do nicely as a cover of a magazine... I'm not sure about the border, I'm not big on borders, and I don't think most magazine covers have borders, but it's not too big of a deal. This is a plain simple nice looking photo that fits the challenge. Good job.

PLAYBOY
by dan_pendleton

Comment:
I'm pretty sure this is not what the magazine is about. I don't think this fits... sorry bout that... In terms of a snapshot, hey it's nice... I'm sure the couple wouldn't mind having it on their wall...

Nashville Skyline
by daemoni

Comment:
Personally I do not consider magazines to be in a horizontal shape... thats just me though. Interesting.. I guess it's definitely the sky with some birds in it. I would have upped my shutter speed a bit so that the right hand bird wouldn't have had a blurry wing. Also the random wing coming in at the top left is bothersome.

The Face
by kate_rio

Comment:
This is much too tiny to see much detail. I also can't tell if it's sharp or not, I'm sure it is, but I just can't tell. I'm not sure if The Face is a magazine, I can find Face magazine... but not The Face. I'm not doubting it is, I just have no clue what the magazine is about so I can't accurately judge if this photo would be good for the front of it or not.

National Geographic
by ashwin

Comment:
Personally I do not consider magazines to be in a horizontal shape... thats just me though. This does not fit the challenge in any way shape or form. I didn't see the challenge saying take a photo OF your favorite magazine, I believe it was to take a photo that could be the front cover of your magazine, I'm not sure NG would ever put a photo of a bunch of their magazines on their magazine. Sorry bout that, but it just doesn't fit.

Golf BC
by brumos

Comment:
Personally I do not consider magazines to be in a horizontal shape... thats just me though. This is a cool photo though, and I could definitely see it as the front of a magazine if it were oriented differently. This is one of the better landscape shots however. This looks like a beautiful golf course.

PC-World
by zeranico

Comment:
Whatever is in the front and blurry is very bothersome... I guess I don't know enough about computers to know what I'm looking at here. Interesting with the smoke or whatever in the background. This could be the beginning of a cover photo.