Freedom
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
Easily recognizable, but not as good as the original, especially in terms of exposure ad POV

Eight Ball — Corner Pocket
by GeneralE

Comment:
A good shot, you achieved to recreate the exact mood. However, DOF and composition are quite different as your lens was too wide.

Reprise, reprise, reprise
by BrennanOB

Comment:
Thanks for choosing my image, I'm flattered :)

Very well done in terms of lighting and overall mood, could just be a tad brighter.
Missing border might be a matter of taste, but I wonder why you flipped the subject?
Also looks like you used a bit much denoising.

At Your Service for Decades Redux - A tribute to Gyaban
by Samantha_T

Comment:
Excellent work, even more appealing than the original (at least for male viewers) only nitpick would be the color of background.

Liquid Pearls
by giantmike

Comment:
Very good attempt, though the lighting is different the composition is almost the same

Big Red (homage to "RED" by ScooterMcNutty)
by smardaz

Comment:
Brave. Where's your dress?
Excellent emulation (model and dress aside), just a tad less elegant, mostly due to the difference in head position and the smaller scarf.

Pears and Pitcher (Still-Life with Fruit)
by grahamgator

Comment:
Really good work, that's what I call a Déja Vu.
Only nitpicks would be the slightly cooler white balance here along with the slightly reduced saturation.

Sunrise 2
by gpuretic

Comment:
Thanks for choosing one of my image, very flattering :)
You did a nice job here, however, I'd like to point out where you missed the mark (difference in flower put aside):
- light on the flower is from above front left instead of front right;
- the orange light on the backdrop is totally missing;
I guess you didn't have access to the proper lighting equipment (or did you just not read my comments under the image?)
- crop is not square
- top of image is too dark
- you could have cloned out some of the imperfections

Orchid On The Steinway / Reprise by h2
by Basta

Comment:
Thank you for chosing my image, much appreciated :)
You did a very good job here, I'd say the image is easily recognizable for other viewers, too.
However, there is a difference (color of the flower aside): the surface seems to be a mirror, not a black material - the reflection is as clear as the original object and even the water (as opposed to my image) has a distinct reflection. Lighting is a bit less directional but more even.
Anyway, the best so far.

Bubbles in Blue
by Dudski

Comment:
Dang, I also tried that but didn't succeed. Your's is almost perfect (should be flipped horizontally).