Messynoodles
by Mazka

Comment:
Messy noodles? I swear I see rice. It might have been better without the frame, or at least a different coloured frame. The picture is quite out of focus to me, but you know what? You picture makes me feel like eating it already. It's lacking a bit in the composition, could be because the wooden table doesn't allow the dish to contrast very well. The lighting is alright. So overall, this was given a 5 from me.

Clear Soup
by e301

Comment:
It's a good picture, but it lacks a bit of compostition for me. I think you're spot on on lighting, but the presentation compared to others was not as attractive and appealing to me. It could be because of the low contrasting colours. So say if you could have a different colour ceramic bowl, it would have contrasted much better with the white background. I'm not sure what the background is, but the lines distract me a bit from the centre piece. It's a certainly good drawn in though. I gave this a 5.

INDIAN SALTY DISH(DALL)
by sandeepsalwan45

Comment:
Honestly, when I saw this thumbnail, I said to myself I'd probably be giving this a 6 or 7. No offense, but once I enlarged it, it was such a big disappointment to me. The quality itself isn't very great, blurry so to speak. The set up is not so great. I gave this a 4, so I thought it deserved an explanation rather then just giving a low score and you not knowing why.
The colour contrast in the food is not great. Usually, for me top view doesn't work well. So if you could have placed somewhere else except in the centre, and given it a more side view and a few enhancements it might have faired a lot better.

Gigantic Paëlla
by charie

Comment:
Looks like it's all in a huge frying wok, since those peas are unbelievably small on this shot. It's not a bad thing of course. The composition is quite good. A variety of contrasting colours makes it even more appealing. Great focus as well, draws you to the shrimp. I giving this a 7.

Chocolate Chip Cookies
by stare_at_the_sun

Comment:
You make my mouth water already. Great composition, but I think I would have liked to see better focusing on one of the cookies. Either that or my tummy is growling like a maniac. Personally if you have used a different surface to put these cookies on, it might has been better. This is a 7 for me.

Gung Gaeng Panang Kao Suey
by michael_p

Comment:
Thai food. The food looks great and so is the presentation. Thai food is known for it's freshness, well at least in my family. I think the presentation is innovative in the sense that is has a fusion Chinese set up to it. Usually these dishes are not eaten with chopsticks, but with a fork and spoon. I won't judge on that. I think your focal point was the panang, but it somehow went out of focus around the huge broccoli.
The colour is very faded as well. Shaped carrots are very pale and look unappetising, so I'll throw a 7 your way for this. None the less the composition works very well.

Domino Sugar Cubes Ad Gone Wrong
by literaryradical

Comment:
I'm honestly surprised this didn't even break a 5 at least as well as the amount of people that gave you a 1. I'm guessing they're quite close minded or just one of those people who gives everyone a 1 in hopes for their picture to score better.

Domino Sugar Cubes Ad Gone Wrong
by literaryradical

Comment:
Great shot! Provoking in some sense, but I cetainly love it. I personally think if you could have made it look like she popped out from the fridge, boy that would be awesome. None the less, I give this shot a 7. Great composition.

Love
by sadiepike08

Comment:
I gave a 4 on this. I don't see the phobia or anything that would provoke phobia to me. Well, maybe it's because some people are terrified of love. Love is beautiful, and it's creative what you made out of snow, so that's how I gave you 3 points, and another 1 point for the effort of placing this shot in the challenge. Normally, small photos won't score very well, so if you have the chance try using the 640 pixels. The composition isn't great in the shot, and it's still rather grainy. Try not to use the camera flash, it hurts the shot too much.

Taphephobia
by fadedbeauty

Comment:
I have been constantly been changing this shot's score between a 7 and an 8. I definitely love the concept, and whole you've got an awesome model, whether it was you (the photographer) or someone else. Immaculate really, but the biggest flaw was within the eyes. Fear is not written all over the eyes, instead curiousity is the message I got in the eyes. It's also great you thought of the hand language. It helped out a lot in the composition and atmosphere of the shot. There's a softness in the hand gesture. Personally, I would have thought it would be better if the hands were stretched out a but more. So I think I'll give this a 7. Sorry though. I really this it's a fantastic shot none the less.