Buttermilk Falls 1
by wrosenberg

Comment:
oh - sooo pretty, but, and you're probably sick of hearing it - (too small) - seems like a lovely capture of that moving water - from what I can make out :)

The Hudson in the fall
by noeul

Comment:
oh! I'd be curious to know where this is specifically - I've lived in different ares of Hudson Valley for several years now, I certainly like the colors, nice work :)

The Garbage Collector
by lady

Comment:
I understand by your title that this must be the garbage collector - but I still do not feel it meets the challenge, this could be a snapshot of any guy off the street and how would any of us know differently? Perhaps if he was shown with the garbage or in any kind of action with the garbage so that we could verify for ourselves that he is in fact "The Garbage Collector" - nice snapshot though :)

Pristine Country Living
by Twyla

Comment:
very nice composition - certainly meets challenge, bottom is a little bit dark on my monitor - but I think it might be good that way - nice job :)

crushed
by redmoon

Comment:
i like this a lot - it's probably my favorite soda can image in the challenge, nice clarity and coloring, the border enhances - if it were any thicker it might distract, good work :) - (1 of 2 of my favorite soda can images )

Warhol Rvstd
by messerschmitt

Comment:
this is 1 of 2 of my favorite can shots for this challenge - I really like the use of desat here - nice clear image and certainly meets challenge, nice work :)

Cast Away
by L1

Comment:
aww...nice image though it leaves me a little sad or even scared, like a little girl lost her baby doll or else she was kidnapped! nice clarity on the subject and meets challenge - good job :)

Bad Dog
by Buckeye_Fan

Comment:
awww bad doggie - such a great idea and I don't think there are any others like it in this challenge, good job making an image about something more than just "garbage" - and it still fits the challenge really well - nice work :)

lifespan
by tcmartin

Comment:
good composition - excellent lighting, I want to be able to do something like this this someday - good work :)

Garbage Lot
by samnotis

Comment:
I really like this, it doesn't have much compositionally but there is something about it, the white wall on the right, next to the red, the green dumpster on the left and the fence falling down in the center - seem to really balance all out really well. Perhaps it's the editing as I really like the colors and lighting - it fits the challenge and really is a quality image - nice work :)