During The Snow (IMAGE_ID=1286195)
by glad2badad

Comment:
Beautiful bird. More cluttered than the original and the position is different. Hard to direct those animals aren't they?

Liquid State of Mind
by 3DsArcher

Comment:
I found the original by MarkB. Great effort. Of course, impossible to make the same, fluid dynamics. Your image makes me think of Bert in Sesamy Street. A bit more contrast maybe to make it pop more?

Tribute to ursula Image_ID1040987
by DCrest01

Comment:
Ursula used a high light from the top, you used a low light from the left. Your image has more depth to it, I like it more than the original.

Blue Flower
by jomari

Comment:
I assume this refers to the blue flower by clickodak. I like yours a bit better because the shadows are a bit softer.

Lucie's Blueberries
by Lydia

Comment:
I found the original. A good effort to emulate it. Nice old spoon, berries placed exactly the same, similar crop. But it is missing the same feel because you used a very different light source. You used a harsh light from the left while the original was made with a soft (large) light from the right, resulting in very different shadows and emphasis of the shapes.

Tomatoes are good for you
by DistantColours

Comment:
I found the original by IreneM. Your version has a very soft waxed feel to it. The reflections are better controlled in your version. Must have been hard with the reflective fork underneath. Still all those reflections "distort" the round shape of the tomato.

Flora III
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I think it is better than the original and of course a different color. You used a more sculpting light to enhance the shape. Could maybe do with a bit more sharpening.

photographer's eyes see more
by Thamerl

Comment:
Nice soft female touch. It is less intense than the original. To get closer it would need more light in the eye, harsher shadows (less reflection from the left) and a closer square crop. Amazing how the hat is almost exactly the same as the other one in this challenge, the fold, the light spots, etc (except for one small damage).

My Polaroid (by Wildpurple)
by Tiberius

Comment:
This is quite a free interpretation of the original (not emulated as close as possible). The angles are different, the light is, the camera is, the flowers are. The original is much more clean. But what bothers me the most is the dirt around the lens opening.

Drop of Honey (Jacko, #23317)
by hajeka

Comment:
The original has the reflection a bit better controlled, not going through the H, and some more surface tension. Maybe you waited a bit longer after placing the drop. But a good effort anyway. 6 for now.