Autumn Morning
by hahn23

Comment:
Yes! Someone gets the meaning of the S-Curve as a compositional tool! And a really nice shot to boot.

"S" is For Street!
by 777STAN

Comment:
That's a pretty dramatic tilt. I'm not seeing the purpose though. It doesn't seem to add any interest.

ancient gracefull lady with artistic "S" curves in her body
by ankit_mohabansi

Comment:
Not trying to be mean here but as part of the purpose of this site is to learn, I wanted to make mention of the point of the challenge.

An S-Curve is a compositional tool, like the rule of thirds or leading lines, that helps in making the image stronger. Normally, the S-Curve is to lead the viewer's eye through the image or to the subject. I've noticed a lot of submissions that simply include an S shape somewhere in the image but this misses the point.

If used properly, the S-Curve is a very powerful compositional tool. While your shot is nice, the "S" that you've included is really just an element and doesn't really lead the viewer's eye.

I do hope you'll take this as I mean it. I certainly don't mean to criticize your image.

Sonata
by craigester

Comment:
this is a beautiful shot and I voted well for it. That said, the challenge isn't strongly represented in your shot and I would have voted better for it if the challenge were more prominent in your shot.

Cape Kiawanda Oregon
by willhadl

Comment:
This is a really nice sunset. That said, the concept of the s-curve is a device that leads the viewer's eye either through the image or to the subject. I'm not getting either in this (very nice) shot. Your subject, the intersection of the sunset and the rock's silhouette, is so strong as to take control of the image.

Please don't think I'm just ragging your shot. It really is a great shot. I'm just not getting the challenge from it.

500miles
by Gmit

Comment:
I'm not sure if it was intentional but your image has a lot of noise. To be honest, I actually like it on the derailer itself but it's pretty distracting in the background. I'd love to see you do this image, again, with a cleaner back ground but maintaining the noise on the derailer itself.

None more Precious
by UrfaK

Comment:
I'm not sure what you're trying to tell me by including the apple

You are my Angel
by j_nusrat

Comment:
You're making me seriously miss Newcastle

The Silence Of The City
by latentflip

Comment:
Excellent job of bringing the eye to your subject by using the tree's as a frame.

Dawn at Fisherman's Point
by Bud

Comment:
Makes me want to leave work, right now, and go fishing!