trees are kool
by picturesr4koolkids

Comment:
ok,

nice color, great light, nice texture, b&w good, nice lines, however, there is another pix in this challenge that has trees that shows the 'collection' aspect of this challenge. I'm sorry to say, I don't get that impression with this pix. It looks like you opened the back door to your house and took a quick snap shot of the fist thing you saw.

Christmas Past
by missinseattle

Comment:
ok,

b&w good, texture great, lighting just ok, dof ok, however the word 'collection' means more than one. This pix does not convince me of that feeling.

Tater Collector
by xtpix

Comment:
Ok, this is my thoughts

Nice idea, color a bit flat, lighting flat, b&w ok, texture great, bg deer distracting.

I'm sorry to say, but the 'taters' look like standard rocks to me, so therefor the pix is not convincing.

November Fishing in Montauk
by ilemme

Comment:
OK, this is what I see

Nice color, nice lines, b&w good, nice dof, however, how does this relate to the theme of this challenge.

Leave me Not!
by doctabrez

Comment:
OK, this is what I see.

color nice, lighting not bad, a bit noisy, b&w good, as for the theme of this challenge??? A pet is not a collection.

toy collection
by Tati

Comment:
Ok, this is what I see.

blacks and whites good, sepia nice, texture good, too many distracting elements, Your title says one thing, and the picture says another, lighting uneven, overall could of been thought out more and done differantly for your viewer.

Leaves
by jsolsona

Comment:
Ok, this is my thoughts.

Color nice, texture nice, blacks good, whites barely in, no dof, lighting flat, no lines, overall not very interesting.

Come on, couldn't you find something to tantalize the imagineation?

Multi-Fandom Figurines
by chet

Comment:
Ok, this is what I see.

Great color, blacks and whites good, crisp, however....

Staged, uninteresting concept, lighting flat, curtan distracting, dof needs work, crop needs work, overall not very interesting.

With all this subject matter, you could of created a story, but instead I see an Ebay sale.

Rub a Dub Dub
by jenesis

Comment:
very memorable.

Bone collector
by alithenake

Comment:
nice idea, but that shadow makes things distracting.

ligting nice, great lines, black good, whites need work, nice texture.