Silhouette
by mannen

Comment:
Meets challenge well and not a bad silhouette. The clouds seem a bit pixilated, perhaps oversharpening?

Grinstone Bridge
by dustin03

Comment:
I think the thing that hurts this shot is the lighting. I like the DOF and I like the idea, but the colors and lighting are dull and the image in the foreground isn't sharp enough. Meets challenge superbly though.

...cutting it right...
by miss parker

Comment:
I like the title and the idea. The lighting has a bit of an orangish tungsten feel to it. With different lighting and a little sharper focus all around I'd have scored this a bit higher.

Tuning Pegs
by dr rick

Comment:
I love the different hues of gold, the lighting, the sharpness, etc. Great photo. While I wouldn't say it doesn't meet the challenge this shot does not strike me as having strength in the right angles themselves. In any shot where I have to think "Are there right angles" I think the submission fell a bit short of really using the photo to communicate the challenge. It's still a great shot and even without a powerful tie to the challenge I gave it an 8.

Perpendicular
by LindaE

Comment:
Great choice of colors to contrast. The blue bars have some pixilation and the cropping of the top makes the blue bars feel a bit slanted and takes away from the right angle. I'm not sure if they are slanted or it's just the way they are framed.

Interlocked
by e301

Comment:
While I wouldn't dispute that you met the challenge, my eye is drawn more to the rounded part of the right fork than the right angles. I just don't feel right angles from this composition.

Technically I would suggest a slightly different DOF with the forks sharper and the background quite a bit softer. I like the lighting quite a bit, though if I were going to nit pick I'd like to get rid of the flare on the rounded part of the right fork (maybe that's why my eye goes there)

Sky Crossing
by roleychiu

Comment:
I really like the blue in the background, but the blue spots on the white X are really distracting. Maybe pushed PS a little too far on this one.

Three x Three
by sahko

Comment:
Creative interepretation of the challenge. I might have titled it "Tic Tac Toe" :)

Holocaust Memorial by Rachel Whiteread
by ramone

Comment:
Really meets the challenge. I wonder if it would be beter to have the middle be centered in the picture as well. so the left and right sides are symmetrical.

Cross and Sky
by Jacko

Comment:
Excellent coloring including a very nice silloutte. I like the DOF also. Having it centered makes it more more dramatic, I like that.

One nit pick -- The right side of the cross between the pedestal and the cross beam has some "pixilation" There are two prominent spots near the cross beam among others.. It might be from the lighting not sure. My eye is drawn to them everytime for some reason.