Patterns
by HBunch

Comment:
This picture is hurting for some kind of focal point. You could've PS'ed something into one of the windows to give it something. It's not quite sharp and also it's just too drab. - Inspzil

Waiting
by emorgan49

Comment:
This is one of the best pet pictures I've seen on this sight. I'm partial to Rot's too. The chin resting on the windowsill is the best. The curtain is a slight distraction but only slight. The look on the dogs face is enough for me to give this a 10. But it is a biased 10 mind you. So if you think it isn't fair, PM me and I'll knock it down to an 8 based solely on picture quality. Great Pic!! - Inspzil

Farmhouses in Iceland
by IceRock

Comment:
This pic needs to be a little sharper and maybe a little bigger wouldn't hurt. - Inspzil

Red 139
by Jak

Comment:
This pic needs to be squared up. Red doors are okay. The picture needs a little more of a focal point IMO. - Inspzil

Blue Window Dream
by MajorChaos

Comment:
Great effect! Love the colors and the slight pitch of the window too. it really works for this pic. Great job! - Inspzil

winter afternoon shadows
by kenbo

Comment:
If you could've gotten the top of the teepee, I think it would've been preferred. That little bit of difference would've made this look like a picture on the wall as opposed to a door, even with the shadows the way they are. It looks not square to the pic but I think that's the angle from which it was taken. Nice shot - Inspzil

Drive 55?
by r_sandler

Comment:
Critique Club by Inspzil

Composition - Great composition overall. The thing that I like most about this is the placement of the white sign on the tree background. This works extremely well. It makes the sign jump off the picture like it was PS'ed on there. Outstanding. The slight (or a little more than slight) also makes even more contrast to the sign. Everything about this picture puts the attention to the sign, which is what I'm assuming you had intended to do. The sky color is terrific. The only thing that is mildly distracting to the sign are the couple of bright lights next to it. But what can you do? Also I think it would've helped a little if the sign were at a right angle with the horizon. Overall, this is well done.

Photography - You hit the exposure on the head. It is as well done as I think it could be. The DOF is hard to judge due to the motion blur, so we'll say that's well done too. You've performed the panning technique very well IMO. Outstanding

Processing - This photo could've used a little rotation to make the sign level to the horizon. You probably could've saturated the colors a bit more and still made it look authentic. It by no means needs the colors done. Squaring the sign up would've made the most dramatic change to this pic, and for the better.

Overall - This is a very well done pic. A couple of minor adjustments and I think it would've reflected in the score. This photo is very underrated in my opinion mostly because the viewers don't like to see blur in the photos. Sometimes we intend it to be that way and I think that it can easily be recognized by this photo that it is very intentional. Excellent pic. It was a fun one to critique. Thanks for sharing it with DPC! - Bob

The Window of Truth
by Mieka

Comment:
This is a very good pic with a very creative effect added to make it really exceptional. Terrific result - Inspzil

Abandoned
by RiderGal

Comment:
I don't like the foreground stuff. If this picture were taken from 5 feet further back I think the effect would still be achieved and the foreground stuff not so noticeable - Inspzil

The Sanctuary
by Rackat

Comment:
Great angle. Wonderful color and great DOF. Exposure is near perfect. I think exposed just a bit more would've made this picture better, slightly. It is excellent as is though. Great photograph and thanks for sharing it - Inspzil