the watchtower
by roba

Comment:
Burn/darken top 1/2 of this shot and I'd give it a 10. I really like the lower 1/2 a lot! overall I give this a 8 :-) gl in challenge

The Overlook
by DrAchoo

Comment:
i love everything about this picture, the smooth sand/washed area, the texture of cluff and tree branches, the perspective, the rocks/boulders in water. However. something about that 1/4 inch line between the far horizon and the water makes me wish you cloned it out with more water???overall I still give this a 9 +++ and really may bump to a 10...gl with challenge :-) yeah i bumped to 10..gl

Last Man Standing
by runeric

Comment:
nice browns :-) nice linear lines, good title overall 7 ..gl in challenge :-)

Lone Tree on the Hill
by lifternessjt

Comment:
lotta red appears in this image on my monitor (however I'm on laptop). I like the composition. just not sure about the flat pale turquoise of sorts sky, moss green ground with red (think might be dead brown grass?) gl in challenge :-)

Old Twisted Pine
by hahn23

Comment:
any way to sharpen the top third of this? I do like the bark, mosquite tree??? and the contrast of shapes, twisted limbs, trunk to rounded hills and mountains. nice colours overall..perhaps shade darker or more saturation on blues and greens? score this an 8 easily and wish you best of luck in challenge :-)

Lifeless Oak
by Ian-Andrew

Comment:
nice idea here. just read an article on how to add "punch" or pop to black and white images..but dang if I could tell ya how to do that. I do know you can add some to this photo and have a really really nice shot...check with one of the PP guru's on the site? overall I give this a 7 due to concept and light from right...gl in challenge :-) 7

Yellow
by 3DsArcher

Comment:
you surely made a 'single tree' stand out as subject. If you could do a layer to blur everything other than the front tree and grass line from the base of that trunk and add tad more "pop" to tree itself you'd have a great shot here. overall I give this a 8..gl in challenge :-)

Barely There
by sallyjo1

Comment:
too darn bad ya couldn't crop out the rest of the road edge without losing left top of tree. nice grass, nice corn, nice tree shape and title...overall I score this at an 8. gl in challenge :-)

Late Summer Oak
by FrostyPaws

Comment:
nice shot..tree is flat and dark? sky is light and flat? check with bradp or bearmusic or anyother PP expert on how to make the tree pop? gl in challenge :-) 8

"Bark's" Eye View
by derekmartinig

Comment:
hmmmm I love the colors, light, bark, blue background, etc..10 on that...now the limb of the single tree being subject i'm not sure of so 8 there..overall I give this a 9 :-) gl in challenge