Freedom - The Open Door
by Spanish_Grease

Comment:
With no disrespect intended whatsoever to all the patriotic 9/11 inspired entries which give thought to that tragedy, I am pleased to see this alternative interpretation of the challenge theme. I love the simplicity of the shot and the choice of such dark shadows, whilst initially something I wasn't sure about, has grown on me - this makes me think of childhood nights... wide awake when I should have been asleep and longing for the freedom to join the lively adult conversation downstairs.

"Katyn Remembered" (Soviet atrocities upon defenders of Poland in WWII) (A 50 foot tall mo
by GolferDDS

Comment:
A beautifully taken image.
And yet I feel the title is very detrimental. Far better (in my opinion) to put only the title of the monument, and add, at most, the name of the country. People can look up the significance if they wish.
I certainly don't think it's helpful to add the height - it seems to me like an instruction to the viewer on how to "see" the image.
That said, it's an attractive image, nice lighting and composition.

Trinity
by crabappl3

Comment:
Woo Hoo Mr!

Looking for pastures new
by BlueDragon

Comment:
I guess it's just that, looking at the image, that story you have just shared just isn't visible. I agree that there is sadness knowing that fact!

lonely roads
by magnetic9999

Comment:
I'd say in some contexts roads are paths travelled but the title didn't seem to have that loose kind of feel to it to suggest it.

Perhaps the title could have been something like "The Road Less Travelled" which would be a rip off I know but...

Shrug!

Desolated
by Remie

Comment:
I'm sorry this didn't rate higher as it's my very favourite of all the entries. I guess everyone didn't feel as strongly as I did about it. I really think it's so evocative.

A Brush with Decay
by moodville

Comment:
Beautiful - such a vivid colour capture and the quality of light is so rich. I love the way you've focused in on the detail and also your diagonal composition.
9

Desolation on my head
by Saro

Comment:
Out of focus, overly red, certainly not visually appealing to look at.
I can see that this was an attempt at a humourous entry but it just doesn't work on any level for me.
3

Peek
by Alecia

Comment:
Woo Hoo 'lecia Bunny!
Want congratulatory pie?
Mmmmmmmmmm Pie!

Abandonned
by orussell

Comment:
Very serene, lovely interruption to the horizon and that gentle, subtle cloud works well for me. Good choice to go black and white, toning seems a bit purple to me.
7