Roscoe: The Mod Cat
by kdkaboom

Comment:
I too, believe this should have scored higher, it is an excellent portrait! Great lighting, composition, textures, tones, and esp expression! The only thing I would change is to crop it tighter, solely for this venue. Our view is so limited with only 640 pixel length, that you want to get all you can in there, I think. (Perhaps a landscape crop would work better with the lines?) I know when someone submits a photo very small, and I can't see it clearly, it is discouraging. I can't decide if the lack of floor molding is distracting or adds a touch of character.

My Kitty Amongst His Stuffed Friends!
by ebertdj

Comment:
Dang! I like this one, It's a really good catch! good lighting, focus, detail where it belongs. I agree with almost all the comments. I think the presence of the colorful stuffed animals add character, which is an extra element that a lot of perfecting photographers forget. Nice portrait!

"Siesta"
by Wangsack

Comment:
I really liked this one, gave a 9, I only wish the background, what looks like a hap-hazard bed pillow, was a pancho or mexican weave blanket - but well blurred so as not to add too much distracting texture as the pillow does. Beautiful lighting! Great hat, nice dof and other textures.

I think living with two boxers would freak me out too, Selena ;))

Sweet Dreams 2
by Fyzarl

Comment:
I really liked this one and scored it high, but I have to agree with clarmore on why it may have not scored higher, plus I think the red in the foreground is a little over-powering, distracts some from your wonderful subject. Otherwise, very nice tonal range and detail. :)

Contact
by Pano

Comment:
I scored you high because I felt it was really well done and I know how difficulst it is to do a fish shot! I only wish the snail was easier to see. Great focus and the translucence is daring. I agree with all the other comments. I guess it didn't strike enough 'cutsie fancies'.

Doggles
by K-Rob

Comment:
Really a great shot, don't know why it did not do better, accept ignorance? My friend has some doggles, and her dog absolutly freezes still when they are on! Great focus and dof, great catch with the tongue! The only thing that bugs me is the yellow reflection under his eye. Gave you a 10 anyways :)

pink sail
by kevrobertson

Comment:
Nice color! I would only wish to see it virticle with more sale and more reflection in the water.

POWER
by megryan

Comment:
Excellent perspective, tonal range, and emotion provoking. I hate it an admire simultaniously. If only the wood prop could have been hidden...

Heaven and Earth
by arnit

Comment:
Excellent, lovely texture and DOF!

in the biginning of the Geysir
by petur-foto

Comment:
Nice idea and contrast, but too out of focus